U.S. Virgin Islands Recovery: Additional Actions Could Strengthen FEMA's Key Disaster Recovery Efforts
Fast Facts
In September 2017, two major hurricanes hit the U.S. Virgin Islands, causing billions of dollars in damage. In response, the Federal Emergency Management Agency provided more than $1.9 billion in grant funding to help repair damaged infrastructure, among other efforts.
FEMA also expanded a pilot program that funded home repairs to allow survivors to shelter in their homes because other emergency shelters weren’t available. FEMA has since decided not to use this program in the future because it was slower to provide help than expected. However, FEMA has not evaluated emergency shelter options for future disasters. We recommended it do so.
Hurricane force winds destroyed public housing apartments in St. Thomas.
Heavily damaged apartment building
Highlights
What GAO Found
As of June 30, 2019, FEMA obligated more than $1.9 billion in grant funding for 640 projects in the U.S. Virgin Islands (USVI) through the Public Assistance program and Hazard Mitigation Grant Program in response to the 2017 hurricanes. However, the limited availability of local USVI personnel to staff key recovery positions and the territory's difficult fiscal situation presented challenges in implementing these programs. Further, FEMA and USVI officials stated they faced challenges with implementing the Public Assistance alternative procedures program, which provides the USVI with flexibility in determining when and how to fund projects. Specifically, these officials stated that developing accurate fixed-cost estimates and using new flexibilities authorized by law delayed longer-term recovery projects. USVI officials told GAO they plan to take a cautious approach when deciding whether to pursue projects using the alternative procedures.
2017 Hurricane Damage in the U.S. Virgin Islands
FEMA expanded its Sheltering and Temporary Essential Power (STEP) pilot program in the USVI to address the lack of other sheltering options for survivors, such as hotels. The program aimed to provide minimal, temporary repairs to damaged homes to quickly make them habitable. In May 2019, FEMA decided it would not use the STEP pilot program in the future since it did not provide assistance as rapidly as intended. Historically, the program was used to address survivors' emergency sheltering needs. However, since ending it, FEMA has not evaluated options for providing future emergency sheltering assistance. Doing so could help FEMA plan for when the next disaster inevitably strikes.
The USVI and FEMA established structures for overseeing recovery efforts. For example, the USVI established a new office to oversee federal recovery programs and FEMA has processes in place to oversee recovery projects at the local, regional, and headquarters levels. However, GAO found that FEMA does not have a consolidated standard operating procedures document for monitoring Hazard Mitigation Grant Program projects. Assessing the need for a consolidated document would help FEMA determine whether its existing guidance should be strengthened.
Why GAO Did This Study
In September 2017, two major hurricanes—Irma and Maria—struck the USVI, causing billions of dollars in damage. FEMA is the lead federal agency responsible for assisting the USVI to recover from natural disasters. FEMA administers the Public Assistance program and Hazard Mitigation Grant Program in partnership with the USVI government, providing grant funding for response and recovery activities, including life-saving emergency protective measures, the repair or replacement of public infrastructure, and measures to increase the territory's resilience during future disasters.
GAO was asked to review the federal government's response and recovery efforts in the USVI. This report examines (1) the status of Public Assistance program and Hazard Mitigation Grant Program funding and challenges, if any, with implementation, (2) the STEP pilot program, and (3) the oversight of these programs. GAO reviewed documentation and data on the Public Assistance program and Hazard Mitigation Grant Program in the USVI as of June 30, 2019. GAO interviewed FEMA and USVI officials regarding the status of recovery efforts and associated challenges, and conducted site visits to the USVI islands of St. Croix, St. Thomas, and St. John.
Recommendations
GAO recommends that FEMA (1) evaluate its options for providing emergency sheltering and (2) assess the need for a consolidated standard operating procedures document for the Hazard Mitigation Grant Program. The Department of Homeland Security concurred with these recommendations.
Recommendations for Executive Action
| Agency Affected | Recommendation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Emergency Management Agency | The FEMA Administrator should evaluate the agency's options for providing future emergency sheltering assistance. (Recommendation 1) |
Closed – Implemented
DHS concurred with our recommendation and has taken actions to fully implement it. Specifically, as of August 2020, FEMA has taken steps to evaluate the agency's options for providing emergency sheltering to disaster survivors following future disasters. To conduct this evaluation, FEMA reviewed a range of existing documentation, including findings from after action reports conducted following prior disasters and the agency's Continuous Improvement Program. FEMA determined that using a combination of existing capabilities and building capacity for specialized teams tasked with coordinating with state, local, tribal, and territorial governments to identify viable sheltering options would ensure FEMA's ability to provide emergency sheltering to disaster survivors. Based on these actions, we consider this recommendation closed as implemented.
|
| Federal Emergency Management Agency | The FEMA Administrator should assess the need for an agency-wide consolidated standard operating procedures document for the Hazard Mitigation Grant Program that provides detailed information on the roles and responsibilities, requirements, and key tasks and milestones for monitoring and closing out program projects. (Recommendation 2) |
Closed – Implemented
DHS concurred with our recommendation and has taken actions to fully implement it. Specifically, in February 2021, FEMA published a new webpage to consolidate guidance on its Hazard Mitigation Grant Program in one location for easy reference. Further, in January 2022, FEMA completed a new Hazard Mitigation Assistance Monitoring Field Guide, a Hazard Mitigation Assistance Closeout Field Guide, and several checklists and fact sheets for FEMA personnel's use in managing its hazard mitigation programs. Based on these actions, we consider this recommendation closed as implemented.
|