Skip to Highlights
Highlights

The Department of Defense (DOD) is pursuing a policy that promotes performance-based logistics at the platform level as the preferred product support strategy for its weapon systems, based in part on DOD's perception that this is an industry best practice. GAO was asked to compare industry practices for activities using complex and costly equipment with life-cycle management issues similar to those of military systems to identify lessons learned that can be useful to DOD. This is the first of two reports addressing DOD's implementation of performance-based logistics and is intended to facilitate DOD's development of new guidance on the use of this approach.

Skip to Recommendations

Recommendations

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status
Department of Defense 1. In order for the department to improve the implementation of performance-based logistics, the Secretary of Defense should direct that the Under Secretary of Defense (Acquisition, Technology and Logistics) and the Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller) to incorporate in DOD's guidance to the services the private sector's practice of using performance-based logistics as a tool to achieve economies at the subsystem or component level, rather than as a preferred practice at the platform level. Also, the Secretary of Defense should direct the Undersecretaries to incorporate the private sector's practice of using it when sufficient performance data are available to establish a meaningful cost baseline.
Closed - Implemented
In response to GAO's recommendation, the Department stated that it recognizes the need to emphasize the use of performance-based logistics for subsystems and components in its policy memorandum and guidebooks. Shortly after GAO's report was provided to the agency for comment, the Department issued a policy memorandum that states that performance based logistics strategies may be applied at the system, subsystem, or major assembly level depending upon program unique circumstances. DOD also has also finalized its Defense Acquisition Guidebook and updated its guidance for implementing performance based logistics found in the Performance Based Logistics: A Program Manager's Product Support Guide. GAO believes this policy and new guidance adequately changes the Department's previous policy, which was to implement performance-based logistics at the weapons system platform level.
Department of Defense 2. In order for the department to improve the implementation of performance-based logistics, the Secretary of Defense should direct that the Under Secretary of Defense (Acquisition, Technology and Logistics) and the Under Secretary of Defense(Comptroller) to consider requiring program offices, during weapon system acquisition, to develop acquisition strategies that provide for the future delivery of sufficient technical data to enable the program office to select an alternate source--public or private--or to offer the work out for competition if the performance-based arrangement fails or becomes prohibitively expensive.
Closed - Implemented
In response to GAO's recommendation, DOD stated that it will take corrective action in its next revision of acquisition regulations DOD 5000.1 and 5000.2. DOD stated that its revised policy will require program managers to develop data management strategies that provide access to the minimum data necessary to sustain the fielded system, re-compete or reconstitute the sustainment workload, and promote the real time access to data at the point of need for the intended user. According to DOD, the strategies will include acquiring the appropriate technical data to support a sustainment exit strategy should performance-based sustainment fail or become too expensive. In May 2005, the Defense Acquisition Policy Working Group (DAPWG) announced its intention to update the DOD 5000 series of acquisition regulations. DOD officials said that they submitted technical data policy language to the DAPWG for its consideration. However, the DAPWG personnel responsible for updating the 5000 series were subsequently re-directed to support the efforts of the Quadrennial Defense Review (QDR). While the DAPWG plan to begin addressing changes to the 5000 series in May 2006, OSD officials said the group will not take up revision this summer. At this point, it does not appear that revisions to DOD acquisition policy will be seriously considered until after the first of fiscal year 2007. However, in October 2004 DOD released its Defense Acquisition Guidebookin and in November 2004, DOD updated its Performance Based Logistics Product Support Guide. Both of these guides now contain a discussion of the minimum level of data which program managers must have access to in order to implement alternative sustainment options.

Full Report