Transitioning Veterans: Coast Guard Needs to Improve Data Quality and Monitoring of Its Transition Assistance Program
Highlights
What GAO Found
The United States Coast Guard (Coast Guard), which is overseen by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), lacks complete or reliable data on participation in the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), designed to assist servicemembers returning to civilian life. According to senior Coast Guard officials, a major reason why data are not reliable is the lack of an up-to-date Commandant Instruction that specifies when to record TAP participation data. Consequently, the data are updated on an ad-hoc basis and may not be timely or complete, according to officials. Federal internal control standards call for management to use quality information to achieve the entity's objectives. Until the Coast Guard issues an up-to-date Commandant Instruction that establishes policies and procedures to improve the reliability and completeness of TAP data, it will lack quality information to gauge the extent to which it is meeting TAP participation requirements in the VOW to Hire Heroes Act of 2011.
According to GAO's survey of Coast Guard installations, various factors affected participation, such as servicemembers serving at geographically remote locations or separating from the Coast Guard rapidly. TAP officials and Coast Guard servicemembers GAO interviewed said commanders and direct supervisors sometimes pulled servicemembers out of TAP class or postponed participation because of mission priorities. TAP managers also said they rely on delivering TAP online because many Coast Guard servicemembers are stationed remotely.
The Coast Guard cannot effectively measure performance to ensure key TAP requirements are met because it lacks reliable data and does not monitor compliance with several TAP requirements. Further, the Coast Guard has not established a formal performance goal against which it can measure progress, although federal internal control standards stipulate that management should consider external requirements—such as the laws with which the entity is required to comply—to clearly define objectives in specific and measurable terms. Establishing a goal could help the Coast Guard define expected performance. In addition, the Coast Guard does not monitor TAP requirements regarding the timeliness of servicemembers' TAP participation or their access to additional 2-day classes. Consequently, it cannot know whether servicemembers are starting TAP early enough to complete the program or those who elected to attend additional 2-day classes were able to do so before separation or retirement, as required by the Act. Finally, the Coast Guard lacks an up-to-date Commandant Instruction that establishes the roles and responsibilities of Coast Guard staff in implementing TAP. Federal internal control standards stipulate that management should assign responsibility and delegate authority to key roles throughout the entity. Issuing an up-to-date Commandant Instruction that defines roles and responsibilities would clarify who is ultimately responsible for ensuring Coast Guard servicemembers attend TAP, thereby facilitating accountability.
Why GAO Did This Study
Thousands of Coast Guard servicemembers have left the military and transitioned into civilian life, and some of these new veterans may face significant challenges, such as finding and maintaining employment. To help them prepare, federal law mandated that DHS provide separating Coast Guard servicemembers with counseling, employment assistance, and information on veterans' benefits through TAP. GAO was asked to examine TAP implementation.
This review analyzes (1) the reliability of TAP data on participation levels for Coast Guard servicemembers and the factors that affect participation, and (2) the Coast Guard's performance measures and monitoring efforts related to TAP. GAO interviewed Coast Guard headquarters staff; surveyed 12 Coast Guard installations that conduct TAP (100 percent response rate); collected and reviewed participation data for reliability; and interviewed TAP managers from three installations selected for size and location, and 25 Coast Guard servicemembers at one location. (For a companion report on TAP implementation for separating and retiring servicemembers in other military services, see GAO-18-23.)
Recommendations
GAO is making seven recommendations, including that the Coast Guard issue a new Commandant Instruction establishing data collection policies, set TAP performance goals, monitor timeliness and access, and define roles and responsibilities. DHS agreed with all of GAO's recommendations.
Recommendations for Executive Action
| Agency Affected | Recommendation | Status |
|---|---|---|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should issue an updated Commandant Instruction that establishes policies and procedures to improve the reliability and completeness of TAP data by including when and by whom data should be recorded and updated. (Recommendation 1) |
Closed – Implemented
The Coast Guard concurred with our recommendation. On November 21, 2021, the Coast Guard published an updated Commandant Instruction describing how the Transition Assistance Program (TAP) is administered, including how Coast Guard collects and reports TAP data. This will improve the reliability and completeness of TAP data.
|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should establish a formal performance goal with a measurable target for participation rates in VOW Act-mandated portions of TAP. (Recommendation 2) |
Closed – Implemented
The Coast Guard concurred with our recommendation. On November 21, 2021, the Coast Guard published an updated Commandant Instruction describing how the Transition Assistance Program (TAP) is administered. Also, on December 4, 2020, Coast Guard officials said they were adopting the Department of Defense's (DOD) TAP performance goals and measurable targets and reporting all data to DOD. Accordingly, the Coast Guard's participation rate target is that 85 percent of servicemembers complete TAP requirements.
|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should monitor the extent to which Coast Guard servicemembers participate in TAP within prescribed time frames. (Recommendation 3) |
Closed – Implemented
The Department of Homeland Security agreed with our recommendation and reported the Coast Guard expects to fully transition to DOD's data system, known as TAP-IT Enterprise System, by October 31, 2018. Once the transition has been completed, the agency anticipates Coast Guard will be able to track member attendance for all TAP components and monitor servicemember participation within the prescribed timeframes. As of March 2020, the Coast Guard implemented the TAP-IT Enterprise System to track servicemember participation in TAP and additional 2-day classes.
|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should monitor the extent to which Coast Guard servicemembers who elect to participate in additional 2-day classes are afforded the opportunity to attend. (Recommendation 4) |
Closed – Implemented
The Department of Homeland Security agreed with our recommendation and reported the Coast Guard expects to fully transition to DOD's data system, known as TAP-IT Enterprise System, by October 31, 2018. Once the transition has been completed, the agency anticipates the Coast Guard will be able to track member attendance for all TAP components. As of March 2020, the Coast Guard implemented DOD's TAP-IT Enterprise System to track servicemember participation in TAP and additional 2-day classes.
|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should issue an updated Commandant Instruction that defines the roles and responsibilities of the personnel who administer the program and ensure servicemembers' participation. (Recommendation 5) |
Closed – Implemented
The Coast Guard concurred with our recommendation. On November 21, 2021, the Coast Guard published an updated Commandant Instruction describing how the Transition Assistance Program (TAP) is administered. The instruction defines who is responsible for administering TAP to help ensure Coast Guard servicemembers participate in the program.
|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should, once reliable data are available by installation or unit, enable unit commanders and the higher-level commanders to whom they report to access TAP performance information specifically for the units they oversee so that they can monitor compliance with all TAP requirements. (Recommendation 6) |
Open
The Coast Guard concurred with our recommendation. On November 21, 2021, the Coast Guard published an updated Commandant Instruction describing how the Transition Assistance Program (TAP) is administered and how USCG collects and reports data on TAP compliance. As of May 2023, the Coast Guard will provide training to field Transition Managers on Identifying separating and transitioning members through DoD TAP-IT, with training expected to be done by September 30, 2024. In FY2024, the Coast Guard plans to fully implement member tracking. They are developing training for transition managers regarding the requirements in the updated Commandant Instruction and use of the DoD tracking system to include CAPSTONE, also due to be completed by September 30, 2024. We will consider closing this recommendation when these efforts are complete.
|
| United States Coast Guard | To ensure that all eligible Coast Guard servicemembers are provided the opportunity to complete the Transition Assistance Program (TAP), the Commandant of the Coast Guard should, once reliable data are available, share TAP information with DOD and other interagency partners, such as data on participation in required TAP courses and additional 2-day classes. (Recommendation 7) |
Closed – Implemented
The Department of Homeland Security agreed with our recommendation and reported the Coast Guard expects to fully transition to DOD's data system, known as TAP-IT Enterprise System, by October 31, 2018. Following the transition, officials anticipate they will be able to share data and statistics with TAP's interagency partners. As of March 2020, the Coast Guard implemented DOD's TAP-IT Enterprise System to share TAP performance information with DOD and other interagency partners.
|