An Overall Strategy Is Needed to Strengthen Disease Surveillance in Livestock and Poultry
GAO-13-424: Published: May 21, 2013. Publicly Released: May 21, 2013.
What GAO Found
Under a new approach, the U.S. Department of Agriculture's (USDA) Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) has begun broadening its previous disease-by-disease approach to disease surveillance to one in which the agency monitors the overall health of livestock and poultry and uses additional sources and types of data to better detect and control new or reemerging diseases. APHIS's first effort under its new approach is to monitor the health of the nation's swine herds and identify new sources and types of data on diseases in swine, among other things. In planning documents, APHIS officials have proposed collecting data from farms where swine are raised, markets where they are sold, slaughter facilities, and veterinary diagnostic laboratories, among other sites. For example, APHIS has been monitoring for the presence of pseudorabies--a viral disease of swine that may cause respiratory illness and death--at slaughter facilities, but under the new approach, it has proposed monitoring these facilities for a range of other diseases as well. Key challenges to carrying out this new approach are how best to obtain data from producers, who are concerned that health information about their herds and flocks be kept confidential, and how to obtain health data in sufficient quantity from some animals like feral swine. Resource constraints also present a challenge, according to agency and state officials, given the recent decrease in APHIS's budget of about 14 percent for fiscal years 2008 through 2013.
APHIS has a vision for its new approach but has not integrated that vision into an overall strategy with associated goals and performance measures that are aligned with the nation's larger biosurveillance efforts. The Government Performance and Results Act, as amended, requires federal agencies to develop performance plans that include goals and performance measures. GAO has previously reported that these requirements can also serve as leading practices for planning at lower levels within agencies, such as individual divisions or programs. Developing goals and measures helps an organization balance competing priorities, particularly if resources are constrained, and helps an agency assess progress toward intended results. APHIS has developed a number of planning documents related to the agency's capabilities in disease surveillance in livestock and poultry, which acknowledge that the agency plays an important role in safeguarding public and environmental health. Goals APHIS has identified in these documents, however, focus primarily on processes or activities and do not specifically address outcomes the agency seeks to accomplish or have associated performance measures. Moreover, none of the planning documents indicate how they individually or collectively support national homeland security efforts called for in Homeland Security Presidential Directive 9, which assigns several federal agencies, including USDA, responsibility for establishing a comprehensive and coordinated surveillance system to support early detection of biological threats, including infectious diseases. Agency officials said they plan to develop goals and measures for the new approach. Without integrating its vision into an overall strategy with goals and measures aligned with broader national homeland security efforts to detect biological threats, APHIS may not be ideally positioned to support national efforts to address the next threat to animal and human health.
Why GAO Did This Study
International animal health authorities have stated that disease surveillance in livestock and poultry has as its main purpose the early detection of diseases and disease outbreaks. APHIS has worked closely with states and industry over the past decades to eradicate diseases by, for example, providing states with funding and guidance. But the disease landscape has changed, with rapid global movement of humans and animals, creating new threats. GAO was asked to review federal animal disease surveillance efforts. This report examines (1) USDAs new approach to disease surveillance in light of a changing disease landscape and challenges, if any, the agency faces with this approach and (2) the extent to which this approach is guided by a strategy with measurable goals and supports broader national biosurveillance efforts. GAO reviewed relevant presidential directives, laws, regulations, guidance, policies, documents, and strategic plans related to disease surveillance in animals; visited swine facilities; and interviewed federal, state, and industry veterinarians and other officials.
What GAO Recommends
GAO recommends that as APHIS develops goals and measures for its new approach, it integrate the agency's vision into an overall strategy guiding how this approach supports national homeland security efforts to enhance the detection of biological threats. In their comments, USDA concurred with GAO's recommendation, and the Department of Homeland Security described its commitment to disease surveillance efforts.
For more information, contact Daniel Garcia-Diaz, (202) 512-3841 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Recommendation for Executive Action
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: In April 2017, USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) provided GAO with its Comprehensive and Integrated Surveillance plan, which depicts an overall strategy for implementing its new approach to animal disease surveillance in livestock and poultry and identifies performance goals and measures to support national homeland security efforts to detect biological threats. According to the plan, a fully comprehensive and integrated surveillance system will allow USDA to efficiently assess animal health in the United States. The plan also helps USDA meet the goal of the President's National Strategy for Biosurveillance (2012) to achieve a well-integrated national biosurveillance enterprise that saves lives by providing essential information for better decision-making at all levels. The plan contains four strategic goals with associated measures, including a goal that aims to integrate surveillance strategies with broader national bio-surveillance strategies, such as those developed by the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) National Bio-surveillance Integration Center. The plan also includes an interagency goal to enhance USDA's ability to conduct surveillance effectively and comprehensively across international borders by further collaborating with international animal health groups, such as the World Organization for Animal Health, the Pan American Foot-and-Mouth Disease Center, and the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization. In addition, the plan includes a crosswalk to demonstrate how the plan's strategic goals align not only with USDA's and APHIS's strategic plans, but also with the National Bio-surveillance Integration Center Strategic Plan and the White House Homeland Security Presidential Directive 9. These actions implement GAO's recommendation.
Recommendation: As APHIS develops goals and measures for its new approach to disease surveillance in livestock and poultry, the Secretary of Agriculture should direct the APHIS Administrator to integrate the agency's vision into an overall strategy, with associated goals and measures, that guides how APHIS's new approach will support national homeland security efforts to enhance the detection of biological threats.
Agency Affected: Department of Agriculture