VA Health Care: Additional Action Needed to Assess the Medical Scribe Pilot
Medical scribes help doctors by entering patient information—like symptoms and treatment plans—into electronic health records during visits. This allows doctors to focus more on treating patients and less on taking notes.
Veterans Affairs piloted the use of scribes in 11 of its medical centers from 2020-2022. Scribes assisted providers in the cardiology, orthopedic, and emergency departments—updating electronic health records in real-time during patient visits.
VA addressed 4 of 5 best practices for pilot design, such as creating a plan to evaluate it. But VA didn't look at how or whether the pilot could be expanded. We recommended VA do so.
What GAO Found
The Veterans Health Administration's (VHA) scribe pilot team implemented a medical scribe pilot at 11 Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) medical centers from June 30, 2020, through July 1, 2022. Under the pilot, medical scribes assisted providers in cardiology, orthopedic, and emergency departments by updating electronic health records in real-time during patient visits.
How Medical Scribes May Assist Health Care Providers in Updating Electronic Health Records
GAO found that VHA's design of the scribe pilot was generally consistent with four of the five leading practices for pilot design that GAO had previously identified. VHA (1) established objectives, (2) communicated with stakeholders, (3) developed an assessment methodology, and (4) developed a plan for evaluating the pilot. However, VHA's design did not include plans for a scalability assessment, the fifth leading practice for pilot design. A scalability assessment would examine whether or how the pilot's approach could be expanded for broader implementation across VA. This assessment should identify criteria or standards to inform decisions, such as measures to evaluate the costs and benefits of the pilot. VHA officials told GAO they designed the pilot according to the VA MISSION Act, which did not require a scalability assessment. Conducting such an assessment would help inform VHA's decisions about whether or how it might use scribes beyond the pilot.
VHA officials identified seven initial lessons learned during the implementation of the scribe pilot. Lessons included considering the use of virtual scribes and standardizing scribe onboarding training. VHA officials said they identified lessons from calls with their research partners and pilot participants—including contractors, scribes, providers, and local pilot coordinators—and from their firsthand experiences implementing the pilot. VHA officials told GAO they plan to review the pilot's final evaluations, which may lead to other potential lessons. After reviewing these evaluations, VHA officials told GAO they plan to make lessons available across VHA. Such lessons could help improve how VA medical centers use scribes outside the pilot and help inform an assessment of the scalability of the medical scribe pilot.
Why GAO Did This Study
Medical scribes document patient health information in electronic health records during patient visits. By assisting providers, medical scribes may reduce providers' documentation burden and allow them to focus on their patients. However, VA researchers have found that limited information is available on provider productivity and patient satisfaction when using scribes. To assess the impact of using scribes on provider efficiency, among other things, the VA MISSION Act of 2018 directed VA to increase the use of medical scribes through a 2-year pilot.
The VA MISSION Act also included a provision for GAO to report on the pilot. This report (1) examines VHA's design of the pilot and (2) describes lessons learned that VHA identified from the pilot.
GAO reviewed VA and VHA pilot documentation and interviewed VHA officials, VA researchers, and contractors, as well as pilot coordinators from three VA medical centers that participated in the pilot. GAO selected the medical centers for geographic diversity and to include each specialty care area where VHA assigned scribes for the pilot.
GAO is making one recommendation, that VHA assess the scalability of the medical scribe pilot. VA concurred with GAO's recommendation and identified actions to address it.
Recommendations for Executive Action
|Veterans Health Administration||The Under Secretary for Health should assess the scalability of the medical scribe pilot, including identifying and applying criteria to inform decisions about whether or how to use scribes beyond the pilot. (Recommendation 1)||
When we confirm what actions the agency has taken in response to this recommendation, we will provide updated information.