Skip to main content

Workplace Safety and Health: OSHA Could Improve Federal Agencies' Safety Programs with a More Strategic Approach to Its Oversight

GAO-06-379 Published: Apr 21, 2006. Publicly Released: Apr 21, 2006.
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

Federal workers' compensation costs exceeded $1.5 billion in 2004, with approximately 148,000 new claims filed that year. Because of concerns for the safety of federal workers, as well as the costs associated with unsafe workplaces, GAO described the characteristics of federal agencies' safety programs and the implementation challenges they face, and assessed how well the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) oversees and assists federal agencies' efforts to develop and administer their safety programs.

Recommendations

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status
Department of Labor The Secretary of Labor should direct OSHA to develop a targeted inspection program for federal worksites based on the new worker injury and illness data federal agencies are required to collect by requiring that relevant portions or summaries of that data be included in agencies' annual reports to OSHA or by obtaining the data from agencies or worksites through periodic, selected surveys.
Closed – Implemented
OSHA initiated a program for targeted federal agency inspections called Federal Agency Targeted Inspection Program (FEDTARG). Federal worksites with high numbers of lost-time injuries at departments with high injury rates have been selected for inspection. OSHA will further explore long-term strategies for the collection of federal agency injury and illness data, including possible use of a single electronic database such as the Department of Labor's Safety and Health Management Information System (SHIMS). As OSHA's federal agency data collection process improves, its targeting criteria will be further refined. OSHA finished implementing FEDTARG in 2008 and renewed it in 2009, but...
Department of Labor The Secretary of Labor should direct OSHA to track violations disputed by federal agencies to their resolution and ensure that unresolved disputes are reported to the President.
Closed – Implemented
OSHA has developed a separate tracking system in the Office of Federal Agency Programs for disputed violations that are forwarded to the National Office for resolution. There were no unresolved violations at the time of this audit. They anticipate one case to be formally forwarded to the National Office for resolution in the near future, which will be tracked appropriately.
Department of Labor The Secretary of Labor should direct OSHA to conduct evaluations of the largest and most hazardous federal agencies as required.
Closed – Implemented
The Department of Labor modified its approach for evaluating the level of agency safety and health programming, including methods such as onsite reviews, workplace inspections, occupational injury and illness data analysis, and safety and health report reviews. OSHA closely monitors the performance of the federal agencies in meeting the injury and illness reduction goals of the Presidential Safety, Health, and Return-to-Employment (SHARE) Initiative, originally established in 2004 and renewed for an additional three years through FY09. Many federal agencies have made significant progress in reducing both their total and lost time injury case rates (SHARE Goals 1 & 2). Through the use of...
Department of Labor The Secretary of Labor should direct OSHA to use evaluations, inspection data, and annual reports submitted by federal agencies to assess the effectiveness of their safety programs, and include, in OSHA's annual report to the President, an assessment of each agency's worker safety program and recommendations for improvement.
Closed – Implemented
In 2006, OSHA initiated an enhanced process in reviewing agency reports, injury and illness data, inspection results, new initiatives, and stated accomplishments to assess the quality of federal safety and health programs, focusing on programmatic strengths and weaknesses. It also took steps to enhance the reliability and consistency of government agency assessments. In 2007, agencies were provided a template to use in creating their reports, and their feedback has been systematically placed in a database and analyzed. Expanded information on specific topics was requested, including, for example, motor vehicle safety programs and seatbelt usage, transition to 29 CFR Part 1904 injury and...

Full Report

Media Inquiries

Sarah Kaczmarek
Managing Director
Office of Public Affairs

Public Inquiries

Topics

Occupational health and safety programsOccupational safetyProgram evaluationProgram managementRegulatory agenciesSafety regulationSafety standardsWorkers compensationFederal employeesFederal agenciesSurveysProgram implementation