Federal Land Management:
Chandler Lake Land Exchange Not in the Government's Best Interest
RCED-90-5: Published: Oct 6, 1989. Publicly Released: Nov 22, 1989.
- Full Report:
Pursuant to a congressional request, GAO reviewed the Chandler Lake exchange, which gave the Department of the Interior surface rights to Alaskan native-owned lands and gave the Alaskan native corporations subsurface rights to land within the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) for petroleum exploration, focusing on whether the exchange was in the government's best interest.
GAO found that: (1) although the Chandler Lake exchange accomplished Interior objectives of consolidating federal lands and obtaining access to parklands in the national park, it was not in the government's best interest; (2) the exchange limited natives' use of all-terrain vehicles (ATV) to easements along riverbeds, but they continued to use ATV throughout the lands as before and increased ATV usage in park wilderness areas; (3) the exchange gave one native corporation the right to drill the only exploratory test well within ANWR and to retain exclusive rights to the test data, resulting in its superior position in assessing ANWR oil and gas potential; (4) without the test data, the federal government has a disadvantage in estimating the oil and gas value of the ANWR subsurface and in setting sale terms for possible future leases; (5) the exchange also allowed the natives to select the unspecified 23,040 acres without acquiring Interior's approval, and they chose an area that Interior now considers to hold the highest oil and gas potential within ANWR; (6) the exchange made inapplicable the revenue-sharing provisions of the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act, which would divide the revenues among the 12 Alaska regional corporations; and (7) Interior used its broad authority to avoid procedural requirements otherwise applicable to land exchanges, such as full public review, preparation of environmental impact statements, and disclosure of the fair market value of the land and interest exchanged.
Matter for Congressional Consideration
Status: Closed - Not Implemented
Comments: No congressional action has been taken or is contemplated; therefore, because of the age of this recommendation, it should be closed out.
Matter: Congress should direct the Secretary of the Interior to develop and issue written procedures to execute land exchanges under the Alaska Native Claims Settlement and the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Acts. At a minimum, the procedures should require: (1) the preparation of environmental assessments or environmental impact statements, when appropriate; (2) full review by the public, state, and local governments, and other affected parties, of all aspects of the proposed exchange; (3) justification for determining whether a proposed exchange is in the public interest; and (4) establishment and disclosure of the fair market value of the lands and interests to be exchanged.