U.S. Customs and Border Protection:
Progress and Challenges in Recruiting, Hiring, and Retaining Law Enforcement Personnel
GAO-18-487: Published: Jun 27, 2018. Publicly Released: Jun 27, 2018.
Additional Materials:
- Highlights Page:
- Full Report:
- Accessible Version:
Contact:
(202) 512-8777
gamblerr@gao.gov
Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov
What GAO Found
U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) increased its emphasis on recruitment by establishing a central recruitment office and increasing its participation in recruitment events, among other things. As a result, the number of applications it received for law enforcement positions across its operational components—the Office of Field Operations, U.S. Border Patrol, and Air and Marine Operations—from fiscal years (FY) 2013 through 2017 more than tripled. Also, in November 2017, CBP hired a contractor to more effectively target potential applicants and better utilize data to enhance CBP's recruitment efforts. However, it is too early to gauge whether the contractor will be effective in helping CBP to achieve its goal to recruit and hire more law enforcement officers.
CBP improved its hiring process as demonstrated by two key metrics—reducing its time-to-hire and increasing the percentage of applicants that are hired. As shown in the table, CBP's time-to-hire has decreased since FY 2015. CBP officials stated these improvements, paired with increases in applications, have resulted in more hires. For example, the number of Border Patrol agents hired in the first half of FY 2018 increased by about 83 percent when compared to the same period for FY 2017. However, the hiring process remains lengthy—for example, in FY 2017 it took more than 300 days, on average, for CBP officer applicants to complete the process. Certain factors contribute to the lengthy time-to-hire, including process steps that can be challenging and time-consuming for applicants to complete—such as the polygraph exam—as well as CBP's reliance on applicants to promptly complete certain aspects of the process—such as submitting their background investigation form.
U.S. Customs and Border Protection's (CBP) Time-to-Hire for Law Enforcement Officer Positions, Fiscal Years (FY) 2015–2017
Days |
|||
Law enforcement officer position |
FY 2015 |
FY 2016 |
FY 2017 |
CBP officer |
396 |
365 |
318 |
Border Patrol agent |
628 |
306 |
274 |
Air and Marine Interdiction Agents |
365 |
338 |
262 |
Source: GAO analysis of CBP data. | GAO-18-487
CBP enhanced its efforts to address retention challenges. However, staffing levels for law enforcement positions consistently remained below target levels. For example, CBP ended FY 2017 more than 1,100 CBP officers below its target staffing level. Officials cited employees' inability to relocate to more desirable locations as a key retention challenge. CBP has offered some relocation opportunities to law enforcement personnel and has recently pursued the use of financial incentives and other payments to supplement salaries, especially for those staffed to remote or hard-to-fill locations. However, CBP does not have a formal process for capturing information on all departing employees, such as an exit survey. Ensuring that operational components are systematically collecting and analyzing such information would better position CBP to understand its retention challenges and take appropriate action to address them.
Why GAO Did This Study
CBP is responsible for securing U.S. borders and employs nearly 45,000 law enforcement officers across its three operational components at and between U.S. ports of entry, in the air and maritime environment, and at certain overseas locations. In recent years, CBP has not attained target staffing levels for its law enforcement positions, citing high attrition rates in some locations, a protracted hiring process, and competition from other law enforcement agencies. GAO was asked to review CBP's efforts to recruit, hire, and retain law enforcement personnel.
This report examines CBP's efforts to (1) recruit qualified law enforcement officers, (2) more efficiently hire law enforcement applicants, and (3) retain law enforcement officers. GAO analyzed CBP data on recruitment, hiring, and retention from FY 2013 through 2017, as well as selected data for the first two quarters of FY 2018. GAO also reviewed CBP strategies and the recent contract it awarded to augment its recruiting and hiring activities and interviewed officials from CBP and three other selected law enforcement agencies.
What GAO Recommends
GAO recommends that CBP systematically collect and analyze data on departing law enforcement officers and use this information to inform retention efforts. DHS concurred with this recommendation.
For more information, contact Rebecca Gambler at (202) 512-8777 or gamblerr@gao.gov.
Recommendation for Executive Action
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: DHS concurred with our recommendation and, as of October 2019, had taken actions to implement it. Specifically, CBP implemented an agency-wide exit survey and used this survey to collect and analyze data on departing law enforcement officers. Implementing a CBP-wide exit survey to collect and analyze these data indicates that CBP has committed to understanding its retention challenges. Further, CBP is using these data to inform its retention efforts by identifying the key reasons law enforcement officers cite for leaving the agency and aligning CBP initiatives to address these cited reasons. Based on these actions, we consider the recommendation closed as implemented.
Recommendation: The Commissioner of CBP should ensure that its operational components systematically collect and analyze data on departing law enforcement officers and use this information to inform retention efforts. (Recommendation 1)
Agency Affected: Department of Homeland Security: United States Customs and Border Protection
Explore the full database of GAO's Open Recommendations
»
Dec 3, 2019
-
Immigration Enforcement:
Immigration-Related Prosecutions Increased from 2017 to 2018 in Response to U.S. Attorney General's DirectionGAO-20-172: Published: Dec 3, 2019. Publicly Released: Dec 3, 2019.
Oct 31, 2019
-
Religious-Based Hate Crimes:
DOJ Needs to Improve Support to Colleges Given Increasing Reports on Campuses [Reissued with revisions on Oct. 31, 2019.]GAO-20-6: Published: Oct 25, 2019. Publicly Released: Oct 28, 2019.
Jul 9, 2019
-
Drug Control:
Certain DOD and DHS Joint Task Forces Should Enhance Their Performance Measures to Better Assess Counterdrug ActivitiesGAO-19-441: Published: Jul 9, 2019. Publicly Released: Jul 9, 2019.
Jun 27, 2019
-
Voter Registration:
Information on Federal Enforcement Efforts and State and Local List ManagementGAO-19-485: Published: Jun 27, 2019. Publicly Released: Jun 27, 2019.
Jun 7, 2019
-
Elder Justice:
Goals and Outcome Measures Would Provide DOJ with Clear Direction and a Means to Assess Its EffortsGAO-19-365: Published: Jun 7, 2019. Publicly Released: Jun 7, 2019.
Jun 4, 2019
-
Face Recognition Technology:
DOJ and FBI Have Taken Some Actions in Response to GAO Recommendations to Ensure Privacy and Accuracy, But Additional Work RemainsGAO-19-579T: Published: Jun 4, 2019. Publicly Released: Jun 4, 2019.
May 30, 2019
-
Military Justice:
DOD and the Coast Guard Need to Improve Their Capabilities to Assess Racial and Gender DisparitiesGAO-19-344: Published: May 30, 2019. Publicly Released: May 30, 2019.
May 9, 2019
-
Drug Policy:
Assessing Treatment Expansion Efforts and Drug Control Strategies and ProgramsGAO-19-535T: Published: May 9, 2019. Publicly Released: May 9, 2019.
Apr 17, 2019
-
Priority Open Recommendations:
Department of JusticeGAO-19-361SP: Published: Apr 10, 2019. Publicly Released: Apr 17, 2019.
Mar 21, 2019
-
DNA Evidence:
DOJ Should Improve Performance Measurement and Properly Design Controls for Nationwide Grant ProgramGAO-19-216: Published: Mar 21, 2019. Publicly Released: Mar 21, 2019.
Looking for more? Browse all our products here