F-22A Modernization Program Faces Cost, Technical, and Sustainment Risks
GAO-12-447, May 2, 2012
What GAO Found
Total projected cost of the F-22A modernization program and related reliability and maintainability improvements more than doubled since the program startedfrom $5.4 billion to $11.7 billionand the schedule for delivering full capabilities slipped 7 years, from 2010 to 2017. The content, scope, and phasing of planned capabilities also shifted over time with changes in requirements, priorities, and annual funding decisions. Visibility and oversight of the programs cost and schedule is hampered by a management structure that does not track and account for the full cost of specific capability increments. Substantial infrastructure costs for labs, testing, management, and other activities directly support modernization but are not charged to its projects. The Air Force plans to manage its fourth modernization increment as a separate major acquisition program, as defined in DOD policy and statutory requirements.
Testing of new capabilities to ensure operational effectiveness and suitability is ongoing. Results to date have been satisfactory but development and operational testing of the largest and most challenging sets of capabilities have not yet begun. Going forward, major challenges will be developing, integrating, and testing new hardware and software to counter emerging future threats. Other risks are associated with greater reliance on laboratory ground tests and relocating an F-22A lab needed to conduct software testing. While modernization is under way, the Air Force has undertaken parallel efforts to improve F-22A reliability and maintainability to ensure life-cycle sustainment of the fleet is affordable and to justify future modernization investments. But the fleet has not been able to meet a key reliability requirement, now changed, and operating and support costs are much greater than earlier estimated.
Why GAO Did This Study
The Air Force currently plans to spend $11.7 billion to modernize and improve reliability of the F-22A, its fifth generation air superiority fighter. GAO was asked to evaluate (1) cost and schedule outcomes and (2) testing results and risks going forward in the F-22A modernization program and related efforts. To do this, GAO examined the programs budgets and schedule estimates over time and discussed any changes with program officials, and reviewed progress and results from developmental and operational testing, and plans to mitigate risks and resolve system deficiencies. fighter. Originally designed to counter air threats posed by the former Soviet Union, the post-Cold War era spurred efforts to add new missions and capabilities to the F-22A, including improved air-to-air and robust air-to-ground attack capabilities. In 2003, the Air Force established the F-22A modernization program to develop and insert new capabilities in four increments.
GAO was asked to evaluate (1) cost and schedule outcomes and (2) testing results and risks going forward in the F-22A modernization program and related efforts. To do this, GAO examined the programs budgets and schedule estimates over time and discussed any changes with program officials, and reviewed progress and results from developmental and operational testing, and plans to mitigate risks and resolve system deficiencies.
What GAO Recommends
GAO recommends that DOD evaluate capabilities to determine if future F-22A modernization efforts meeting DOD policy and statutory requirements should be established as separate major acquisition programs.
DOD concurred with our recommendation.
For more information, contact Michael J. Sullivan, (202) 512-4841, firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Closed - implemented
- Closed - not implemented
Recommendation for Executive Action
Recommendation: As new and enhanced capabilities are proposed and vetted beyond Increment 3.2B in the F-22A modernization program, the Under Secretary for Acquisition, Technology and Logistics should evaluate those capabilities in accordance with DOD policy and statutory criteria to determine if they should be established as separate major defense acquisition programs, each with its own milestones, business case, and cost baseline that includes all applicable direct and indirect support costs required to complete the program.
Agency Affected: Department of Defense: Office of the Secretary of Defense: Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition, Technology, and Logistics
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: The F-22A Modernization Increment 3.2B was approved to begin product development at a Milestone B review on May 16, 2013. According to the F-22 Modernization program manager, that approval established the Increment 3.2B program as a new major defense acquisition program. As such, the program will have its own budget and will provide Selected Acquisition Reports to the Congress. In addition, the F-22 Modernization program manager noted that any future F-22A capability upgrades will be established and managed in a similar manner as separate acquisition programs. As an example, he noted that an F-22 capability upgrade following Increment 3.2B, currently known as F-22 Mandates, held a Materiel Development Decision on June 7, 2013. While this capability upgrade program is not expected to be a major defense acquisition program, it will be expected to follow all of the same defense acquisition guidance and complete all required documentation. The start of development for this upgrade program (Milestone B) is currently anticipated to occur in early fiscal year 2016. Taken together, DOD's establishment of Increment 3.2B and the F-22 Mandates upgrades as new distinct acquisition programs meets the intent of our recommendation.