Recommendation: To help ensure the IRS collection program meets its mission and selects cases fairly, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue should establish, document, and implement clear objectives for the collection program and enterprise-wide case categorization and routing processes, and define key terms, such as "fairness" and "risk."

Agency: Department of the Treasury: Internal Revenue Service
Status: Open

Comments: IRS agreed with the recommendation. In March 2017, IRS provided documentation of actions taken on the recommendation, but the documents did not clearly define and communicate program objectives sufficient for internal control to support the collection program mission, including fairness in case selection. In November 2017, IRS provided additional documentation but it did not address case selection fairness or other objectives for the collection program and enterprise-wide case categorization and routing processes. In June 2019, IRS officials provided information on an ongoing IRS initiative to identify objectives for various programs, but the collection program with its case processes was not among the pilot programs. As a result, any actions to implement the recommendation will be stalled until the initiative's pilot programs are complete. As of November 2019, IRS had not provided a planned date when it expects to complete them. We will update the status of IRS's plans and actions to implement the recommendation after we complete review of any documents IRS provides, as we requested in December 2019.

Recommendation: To help ensure the IRS collection program meets its mission and selects cases fairly, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue should build upon existing Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) guidance to help managers identify internal and external risks to collection program objectives, and better understand how long-standing risk processes integrate with new ERM approaches; incorporate this guidance into existing or future ERM or collection program risk assessment processes.

Agency: Department of the Treasury: Internal Revenue Service
Status: Open

Comments: IRS agreed with the recommendation. In November 2016, IRS provided documentation of risk management training for managers intended to assist them in understanding their responsibilities for identifying internal and external risks to collection program objectives. However, since objectives for the collection program and fairness were not yet clearly defined, such guidance could not be effectively incorporated into risk assessment processes. In March 2017, IRS provided documentation of further actions taken, but the documents did not clearly define and communicate program objectives sufficient for internal control, including risk assessment. In November 2017, IRS provided additional documentation but it did not address case selection fairness or other objectives for the collection program. In June 2019, IRS officials provided information on an ongoing IRS initiative to identify objectives for various programs, but the collection program was not among the pilot programs. As a result, any actions to implement the recommendation will be stalled until the initiative's pilot programs are complete. As of November 2019, IRS had not provided a planned date when it expects to complete them. We will update the status of IRS's plans and actions to implement the recommendation after we complete review of any documents IRS provides, as we requested in December 2019.