Recommendation: The Assistant Secretary of Defense for Homeland Defense and Global Security, in coordination with the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and other appropriate DOD components, should update the department's cyber incident coordination training to incorporate the tenets of PPD-41.

Agency: Department of Defense
Status: Open

Comments: DOD partially concurred with this recommendation. When we confirm what actions the agency has taken in response to this recommendation, we will provide updated information.

Recommendation: The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff should maintain a list of senior DOD officials from organizations that could represent DOD during a Cyber Unified Coordination Group and that are trained in the National Incident Management System.

Agency: Department of Defense
Status: Open

Comments: DOD concurred with this recommendation. When we confirm what actions the agency has taken in response to this recommendation, we will provide updated information.

Recommendation: To improve agency information security programs, Acting Director of the Office of Personnel Management should provide and track specialized training for all individuals, including contractors, who have significant security responsibilities.

Agency: Office of Personnel Management
Status: Open
Priority recommendation

Comments: OPM partially agreed with this recommendation. In December 2018, OPM stated that it is working with its learning management system vendor to develop requirements, but had not yet targeted an expected completion date. To fully implement the recommendation, OPM needs to complete its efforts to ensure that it provides and tracks training for individuals with significant security responsibilities. As of March 2020, OPM has not provided evidence that it has completed these actions.

Recommendation: To improve agency information security programs, the Secretary of the Department of Veterans should conduct security control assessments for the two selected systems and ensure the procedures comprehensively test technical controls.

Agency: Department of Veterans Affairs
Status: Open

Comments: VA concurred with our recommendation. The agency has conducted security control assessments for the two systems, but these assessments did not show that technical controls were comprehensively tested. According to VA, the agency will complete the next security control assessment in October 2019 and complete the system assessment report in December 2019. As of March 2020, the agency has not provided evidence that it has implemented this recommendation. Subsequent to VA informing us that it has completed implementation, we plan to verify the agency's actions.

Recommendation: To improve security over federal systems, including those considered to be high impact, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget should issue plan and practices specified in the Cybersecurity Strategy and Implementation Plan.

Agency: Executive Office of the President: Office of Management and Budget
Status: Open

Comments: OMB concurred with our recommendation. On December 9, 2016, OMB issued memorandum M-17-09, Management of Federal High Value Assets, which lists some existing policies and guidance and other actions that agencies need to take to protect IT assets. Further information is needed to validate implementation of the recommendation. As of March 2020, the agency has not provided evidence that it has implemented this recommendation. Subsequent to OMB informing us that it has completed implementation, we plan to verify the agency's actions.

Recommendation: To better monitor and provide a basis for improving the effectiveness of cybersecurity risk mitigation activities, informed by the sectors' updated plans and in collaboration with sector stakeholders, the Secretary of the Treasury should direct responsible officials to develop performance metrics to provide data and determine how to overcome challenges to monitoring the financial services sector's cybersecurity progress.

Agency: Department of the Treasury
Status: Open

Comments: The Department of the Treasury, as the sector-specific agency for the financial services sector, continues to develop initiatives intended to enhance the sector's cybersecurity. In 2016, Treasury developed and promulgated a set of seven fundamental elements or critical building blocks for sector stakeholders' cybersecurity, disseminated a template for financial sector cyber exercises, and promoted the NIST Cybersecurity Framework throughout the sector. However, they have not provided evidence of metrics implemented, and the 2015 sector-specific plan does not include specific metrics to track and report on their effectiveness. We will continue to monitor Treasury's efforts to create specific metrics and related reports on the sector's cybersecurity progress.

Recommendation: To better monitor and provide a basis for improving the effectiveness of cybersecurity risk mitigation activities, informed by the sectors' updated plans and in collaboration with sector stakeholders, the Secretaries of Agriculture and Health and Human Services (as co-SSAs) should direct responsible officials to develop performance metrics to provide data and determine how to overcome challenges to monitoring the food and agriculture sector's cybersecurity progress.

Agency: Department of Agriculture
Status: Open

Comments: The Department of Agriculture (USDA), as the co-sector specific agency for the food and agriculture sector, with the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) continues to implement cybersecurity-related activities for the sector. In particular, USDA, through the sector coordination council, routinely shares best practices and informational bulletins from the Department of Homeland Security on cybersecurity with sector stakeholders via the Homeland Security Information Network. In addition, at semi-annual council meetings, USDA has hosted roundtable discussions of cybersecurity challenges and best practices. No evidence of performance metrics to track and report on the SSAs' activities or the sector's cybersecurity progress has been provided. As USDA and HHS continue to carry out their sector-specific agency role, we will continue to monitor their efforts and associated performance metrics to be developed to demonstrate the effectiveness of these activities

Recommendation: To better monitor and provide a basis for improving the effectiveness of cybersecurity risk mitigation activities, informed by the sectors' updated plans and in collaboration with sector stakeholders, the Secretaries of Agriculture and Health and Human Services (as co-SSAs) should direct responsible officials to develop performance metrics to provide data and determine how to overcome challenges to monitoring the food and agriculture sector's cybersecurity progress.

Agency: Department of Health and Human Services
Status: Open

Comments: The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), as the co-sector specific agency for the food and agriculture sector, with the Department of Agriculture (USDA) continues to implement cybersecurity-related activities for the sector. In particular, through the sector coordination council, they routinely share best practices and informational bulletins from the Department of Homeland Security on cybersecurity with sector stakeholders via the Homeland Security Information Network. In addition, at semi-annual council meetings, they have hosted roundtable discussions of cybersecurity challenges and best practices. No evidence of performance metrics to track and report on the SSAs' activities or the sector's cybersecurity progress has been provided. As HHS and USDA continue to carry out their sector-specific agency role, we will continue to monitor their efforts and associated performance metrics to be developed to demonstrate the effectiveness of these activities

Recommendation: To better monitor and provide a basis for improving the effectiveness of cybersecurity risk mitigation activities, informed by the sectors' updated plans and in collaboration with sector stakeholders, the Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency should direct responsible officials to develop performance metrics to provide data and determine how to overcome challenges to monitoring the water and wastewater systems sector's cybersecurity progress.

Agency: Environmental Protection Agency
Status: Open

Comments: The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) continues to develop and implement activities in support of the water and wastewater sector's cybersecurity such as a cyber-attack risk assessment tool and cybersecurity training for sector partners. The 2015 water and wastewater sector-specific plan calls for assessing performance and reporting on sector cybersecurity progress; however, the plan does not state specific measures. In 2017, agency officials stated that the development of performance metrics in collaboration with sector partners was underway; however, EPA has not provided evidence of the metrics or any tracking effort. As EPA continues to carry out its sector-specific agency role, we will continue to monitor its efforts and associated performance metrics to be developed to demonstrate the effectiveness of these activities.

Recommendation: To ensure that NCUA has adequate authority to determine the safety and soundness of credit unions, Congress should consider modifying the Federal Credit Union Act to grant NCUA authority to examine technology service providers of credit unions.

Agency: Congress
Status: Open

Comments: In July 2015, we suggested that Congress modify the Federal Credit Union Act to grant NCUA authority to examine technology service providers of credit unions. As of July 2020, Congress had not granted NCUA this authority.