Recommendation: To improve the transparency and accountability of HHS's section 1115 Medicaid demonstration approval process, and to ensure that federal Medicaid funds for the demonstrations do not duplicate other federal funds, the Secretary of Health and Human Services should issue criteria for assessing whether section 1115 expenditure authorities are likely to promote Medicaid objectives.
Agency: Department of Health and Human Services
Status: Open
Comments: The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) partially concurred with this recommendation and has taken some steps to address the problems GAO identified. Initially, in August 2015, HHS posted on its website general criteria for assessing whether Medicaid section 1115 demonstration expenditure authorities are likely to promote Medicaid objectives, but GAO found the general criteria were not sufficiently specific. HHS later removed these criteria from its website and replaced them with six broad areas of reform that HHS encourages states to consider. As of January 2020, HHS does not have specific criteria for approving section 1115 expenditure authorities, but officials noted that the agency had begun including in approval letters the agency's rationale for approving specific expenditure authorities. GAO considers this a positive step towards improving the transparency of HHS's approval decisions, and if implemented consistently would address the intent of GAO's recommendation. HHS officials indicated that this step would be included in written protocols the agency is drafting but did not have a date for their completion. If these protocols are completed and consistently implemented, HHS's bases for its approvals of expenditure authorities, which can amount to billions of dollars in federal spending, will be more transparent. We will continue to monitor HHS's actions in response to this recommendation.
Recommendation: To improve the transparency and accountability of HHS's section 1115 Medicaid demonstration approval process, and to ensure that federal Medicaid funds for the demonstrations do not duplicate other federal funds, the Secretary of Health and Human Services should ensure the application of these criteria is documented in all HHS's approvals of section 1115 demonstrations, including those approving new or extending or modifying existing expenditure authorities, to inform internal and external stakeholders, including states, the public, and Congress, of the basis for the agency's determinations that approved expenditure authorities are likely to promote Medicaid objectives.
Agency: Department of Health and Human Services
Status: Open
Comments: HHS agreed with this recommendation and, as of January 2020, had taken some steps to ensure that the bases for its approval decisions are documented in all approvals of section 1115 demonstrations. In December 2017, HHS's Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a letter to state Medicaid officials, stating it had begun requesting additional documentation of the demonstration purposes being served by certain types of previously approved funding in demonstration proposals. Additionally, the agency noted it was taking certain steps to ensure that only allowable costs were matched by federal Medicaid funds. In April 2018, CMS officials stated that the agency had begun addressing in approval documents how each intervention proposed by the state was determined to be likely to promote Medicaid objectives. Officials reported that this step would be included in formal written protocols that outline the agency's procedures for application review and preparation of approval documents for section 1115 demonstrations, but as of January 2020, the agency did not have time frames for the completion of these protocols. If CMS completes and implements the written protocols, stakeholders should be able to more easily and consistently assess the agency's decisions. We will continue to monitor CMS's efforts in this area.
