Skip to main content

Genetically Modified Foods: Experts View Regimen of Safety Tests as Adequate, but FDA's Evaluation Process Could Be Enhanced

GAO-02-566 Published: May 23, 2002. Publicly Released: May 23, 2002.
Jump To:
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

Genetically modified foods pose the same risks to human health as do other foods. These risks include allergens, toxins, and compounds known as antinutrients which inhibit the absorption of nutrients. Before marketing a genetically modified food, company scientists seek to determine whether these foods pose any heightened risks. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) published guidelines in 1992 to ensure that companies worked with the agency to assess the safety of genetically modified foods. GAO found that FDA's evaluation process could be enhanced by randomly verifying the test data provided and by increasing the transparency of the evaluation process, including communicating more clearly the scientific rationale for FDA's final decision on an assessment of genetically modified food. Scientists expect that genetic modifications will increasingly enhance the nutritional value of genetically modified foods. Although current tests have been adequate for evaluating the few genetically modified foods that have, so far, undergone relatively simple compositional changes, new technologies are being developed to evaluate the increasingly complex compositional changes expected. Monitoring the long-term health risks of genetically modified foods is generally neither necessary nor feasible. No scientific evidence exists, nor is there even a hypothesis, suggesting that long-term harm, such as higher cancer rates, results from these foods. Moreover, technical challenges make long-term monitoring infeasible.

Recommendations

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status Sort descending
Food and Drug Administration To enhance FDA's safety evaluations of GM foods, the Deputy Commissioner of Food and Drugs should direct the agency's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition to expand its memos to file recording its decisions about GM foods to provide greater detail about its evaluations of the foods, including the level of evaluation provided, the similarity of the foods to foods previously evaluated, and the adequacy of the tests performed by the submitting companies.
Closed – Implemented
FDA has taken actions to make memos to file more detailed as GAO recommended.
Food and Drug Administration To enhance FDA's safety evaluations of GM foods, the Deputy Commissioner of Food and Drugs should direct the agency's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition to obtain, on a random basis, raw test data from companies, during or after consultations, as a means of verifying the completeness and accuracy of the summary test data submitted by companies.
Closed – Not Implemented
In October 2007, FDA officials indicated that they had discussed this recommendation, but had not decided on a course of action. Citing staffing constraints and other priorities, they indicated that they had no firm plan or time frame for implementing the recommendation. Since it has been more than 5 years since our report was issued (May 2002), we are closing this recommendation as not implemented.

Full Report

Office of Public Affairs

Topics

Agricultural researchEvaluation methodsFood industryGeneticsHealth hazardsHealth research programsSafety regulationAgency evaluationRail transit safetyScientists