Skip to main content

1992 Thrift Resolutions: RTC Policies and Practices Did Not Fully Comply With Least-Cost Provisions

GGD-94-110 Published: Jun 17, 1994. Publicly Released: Jun 17, 1994.
Jump To:
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

Pursuant to a legislative requirement, GAO reviewed the Resolution Trust Corporation's (RTC) compliance with legislative requirements that it use the least costly method to resolve failed thrifts, focusing on: (1) 1992 RTC resolution policies and decisions, specifically its calculation and documentation of the costs of resolution alternatives; and (2) marketing aspects of the RTC resolution process.

Recommendations

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status
Resolution Trust Corporation The Deputy and Acting Chief Executive Officer, RTC, should revise RTC policies to require that the agency estimate liquidation costs as of the earliest of the date: (1) a conservator is appointed; (2) a receiver is appointed; or (3) of a determination to provide assistance to a failing or failed thrift.
Closed – Implemented
RTC disagrees with GAO's interpretation of when the liquidation cost estimate should be calculated. RTC does not plan to fully comply with the recommendation. GAO's review of resolutions done between January 1993 and June 1994 found that, where applicable, RTC effectively implemented the recommendation during the process in which RTC determined the advance dividend to pay uninsured depositors. Further, as of March 1995, RTC had no thrifts in conservatorships and planned to resolve any failing thrifts via its accelerated resolution program, which will enable RTC to make timely estimates of liquidation costs.
Resolution Trust Corporation The Deputy and Acting Chief Executive Officer, RTC, should revise RTC policies to require that the agency evaluate the resolution methods that are potentially available before selling assets of a failed thrift.
Closed – Implemented
RTC does not intend to comply with this recommendation. RTC effectively complied with the recommendation, in that, because of lower interest rates, it found that retaining high-quality assets provided conservatorships a better return than selling the assets and investing the proceeds in lower-yielding Treasury securities. This enabled RTC to retain the assets until close to or at the resolution date before selling them. Also, RTC officials said they plan to resolve all future troubled thrifts via ARP, which renders the recommendation moot.
Resolution Trust Corporation The Deputy and Acting Chief Executive Officer, RTC, should direct the Division of Resolutions to require that the consideration given all nonconforming bids received be documented.
Closed – Implemented
RTC now adequately documents (in the cost summary and cost test) the consideration given all nonconforming bids.
Resolution Trust Corporation The Deputy and Acting Chief Executive Officer, RTC, should direct the Division of Resolutions to revise RTC policies to require that RTC document the rationale for the agency's preferred marketing strategy for resolving a failed thrift.
Closed – Implemented
RTC adequately documents the rationale for its preferred marketing strategy.

Full Report

Office of Public Affairs

Topics

Bank failuresBanking lawFinancial managementInsured commercial banksMarketingMathematical analysisNoncomplianceProperty disposalSavings and loan associationsFailed thrifts