Personnel Practices:

Conversions of Employees from Noncareer to Career Positions May 2001 - April 2005

GAO-06-381: Published: May 1, 2006. Publicly Released: May 25, 2006.

Additional Materials:

Contact:

George H. Stalcup
(202) 512-9095
contact@gao.gov

 

Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov

A federal employee conversion occurs whenever an individual changes from one personnel status or service to another without a break in federal government service of more than 3 days. This report focuses on conversions of individuals from noncareer to career positions. Federal agencies must use appropriate authorities and follow proper procedures in making these conversions. GAO was asked to determine for departments and selected agencies (1) the number and characteristics of all noncareer to career conversions occurring during the period from May 1, 2001, through April 30, 2005, and (2) whether appropriate authorities were used and proper procedures were followed in making these conversions at the GS-12 level and above.

Twenty-three of the 41 departments and agencies selected for review reported converting 144 individuals from noncareer to career positions from May 1, 2001, through April 30, 2005. The other 18 departments and agencies reported making no conversions during this period. Four agencies accounted for 95, or 66 percent, of the 144 reported conversions: the Departments of Health and Human Services (36), Justice (23), Defense (21), and Treasury (15). Of the 144 reported conversions, almost two-thirds were from Limited Term Senior Executive Service (SES) positions (47) and Schedule C positions (46). Limited Term SES appointments may be made for up to 36 months and can include federal employees who previously held career positions. Schedule C appointments are generally noncompetitive and are for positions graded GS-15 and below that involve determining policy or that require a close confidential relationship with key agency officials. Of these 144 individuals, 64 were converted to career SES positions, 47 to career competitive service positions, and 33 to career excepted service (non-Schedule C) positions. Agencies used appropriate authorities and followed proper procedures in making the majority (93) of the 130 conversions reported at the GS-12 level or higher. However, for 37 of these conversions it appears that agencies did not follow proper procedures or agencies did not provide enough information for us to make an assessment. For 18 of the 37 of these conversions, it appears that agencies did not follow proper procedures. Some of the apparent improper procedures included: selecting former noncareer appointees who appeared to have limited qualifications and experience for career positions, creating career positions specifically for particular individuals, and failing to apply veteran's preference in the selection process. Seven of the 18 conversions were subject to OPM review and approval; 2 because they fell within the presidential election pre-appointment review period as prescribed by OPM and 5 because they were to SES level positions. For the remaining 19 conversions, agencies did not provide enough information for GAO to fully assess the process used by the agency in making the conversion. This was largely attributable to the types of appointments involved. Sixteen of these 19 conversions were to career excepted service (non-Schedule C) positions at the Department of Justice. For appointments to excepted service positions, OPM does not require agencies to follow OPM's competitive hiring provisions or to maintain records of the rating, ranking, and selection process, as it requires for competitive service appointments (although most of these conversions are subject to the merit system principles). These unique hiring procedures and limited documentation requirements for excepted service positions resulted in GAO having insufficient information to reconstruct the Department of Justice's decision-making process to convert these individuals. For the remaining three cases, the Department of Health and Human Services could not locate certain files.

Recommendations for Executive Action

  1. Status: Closed - Implemented

    Comments: In its 60-day letter, the Director of OPM directed its Human Capital Leadership Merit System Accountability Division (HCLMSAD) to begin a review of the 18 conversions that we identified. OPM's HCLMSAD completed its investigation of these conversions. Nine of the 18 cases identified by GAO belonged to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). Based on this review, OPM agreed with our preliminary findings in six of the cases, identifying corrective actions for four cases, and determined four cases should be referred to the HHS Office of the Inspector General (OIG). No action was deemed necessary for the ninth case. Of the remaining nine cases, OPM concurred with us in six cases. In one case, OPM had no oversight authority and had no access to the appropriate documents. In two cases, due to employee turnover and poor recordkeeping practices by the agencies involved, according to OPM's Director, neither the documents nor the appropriate staff existed for OPM to make a determination as to whether a serious appointment violation occurred. OPM stated that it would advise all of these agencies on the appropriate corrective actions to be taken and would follow-up to ensure each agency has addressed the problem. OPM's Director stated that of these cases it did not uncover any systemic problems that would require investigation by either an agency OIG or the Office of Special Counsel.

    Recommendation: To help ensure that federal agencies are following appropriate authorities and proper procedures in making conversions of noncareer to career positions, the Director of OPM should review the 18 conversions we identified where it appears that certain agencies did not use appropriate authorities and/or follow proper procedures in making these conversions and determine whether additional actions are needed.

    Agency Affected: Office of Personnel Management

  2. Status: Closed - Implemented

    Comments: In its 60-day letter, the Director of OPM stated that OPM will review its policies and procedures for the review and approval of non-career to career conversions. In a December 19, 2006, letter from OPM's Director to Representatives Waxman and Davis, the Director stated that OPM reviewed its procedures for review and approval of noncareer to career conversions and determined no changes are necessary at this time. OPM stated that it would continue to provide guidance and oversight to the agencies in noncareer to career conversions.

    Recommendation: To help ensure that federal agencies are following appropriate authorities and proper procedures in making conversions of noncareer to career positions, the Director of OPM should determine whether conversions to career excepted service positions should be subject to OPM review--such as through the pre-appointment review OPM conducts of other conversions during presidential election periods, and/or during OPM's periodic audits of agencies' examining and hiring activities, and if so, determine what information agencies should provide on such conversions.

    Agency Affected: Office of Personnel Management

 

Explore the full database of GAO's Open Recommendations »

Nov 20, 2018

Nov 15, 2018

Sep 10, 2018

May 30, 2018

Dec 14, 2017

May 24, 2017

May 18, 2017

Apr 27, 2017

Dec 29, 2016

Looking for more? Browse all our products here