Paid Tax Preparers:
Most Taxpayers Believe They Benefit, but Some Are Poorly Served
GAO-03-610T: Published: Apr 1, 2003. Publicly Released: Apr 1, 2003.
- Highlights Page:
- Full Report:
- Accessible Text:
In tax year 2000, over half of individual filers paid someone to prepare their tax return. These taxpayers paid an estimated $14.7 billion for individual return preparation. Despite the importance of paid preparers' role in the tax system, little data exist on the quality of the services they provide. In light of this, GAO surveyed and interviewed taxpayers and gathered examples of the range of outcomes experienced by taxpayers who used paid tax preparers.
Based on our on-going work, most taxpayers believe they benefit by using a paid tax preparer. According to the results of our nationwide survey, 77 percent of taxpayers said they were very or generally confident that their preparer completed a tax return that allowed them to pay no more in taxes than was legally required. In addition, the survey showed that 87 percent of taxpayers would use a paid preparer in the future. Despite these facts, taxpayers may not understand the tax laws well enough to accurately assess their preparers' performance. To provide quality service, paid preparers must probe the personal circumstances that could affect the amount of tax their clients owe, such as whether the taxpayers have dependents. For example, one taxpayer took 3 years of prior returns prepared by a friend to a tax preparer. The preparer found that the taxpayer had overpaid his taxes by more than $6,200 because he had overlooked earned income and child tax credits. While most taxpayers expressed confidence in their paid preparers, our survey, studies of filed returns, and interviews with knowledgeable observers suggest that a small percent of taxpayers are poorly served due to problem performance by preparers. For example, GAO's survey results indicated that 5 percent of all taxpayers had no confidence that they had not overpaid their taxes. However, even a small percentage of the more than 71 million users of paid preparers in 2000 can translate into millions of affected taxpayers. Preparers who fail to adequately probe, provide questionable advice, or engage in fraudulent practices can cause serious adverse consequences for their clients. For example, one taxpayer overpaid his taxes for several years by about $3,500 to $5,000, despite receiving notices from the Internal Revenue Service that he may be eligible for the earned income tax credit. When he showed these notices to his paid preparer, the preparer took no action. Paid preparers are not always the cause of problems--taxpayers can provide preparers inaccurate or incomplete information. Despite using a preparer, taxpayers are still ultimately responsible for the accuracy of their return.