[Protest of MTMC Evaluation of Bids for Fuel Transport]

B-240087: Jul 6, 1990

Additional Materials:


Edda Emmanuelli Perez
(202) 512-2853


Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800

A firm protested the Military Traffic Management Command's (MTMC) bid evaluation under a solicitation for fuel transport, contending that although its bid was higher, it could perform the work sooner than the awardee. GAO held that it did not exercise jurisdiction over informal procurements of transportation services. Accordingly, the protest was dismissed.

B-240087, Jul 6, 1990, 90-2 CPD 19

PROCUREMENT - Bid Protests - GAO authority DIGEST: Protest concerning request for carriers' rate tenders falls outside of General Accounting Office's bid protest jurisdiction where transportation services will be obtained through the issuance of a government bill of lading pursuant to a tender for a one-time routing under relatively informal agency procedures.


Stapp Towing Company, Inc.:

Staff Towing Company, Inc. protests the evaluation of bids under telephone request No. 1LWX31623-S, by the Military Traffic Management Command-Eastern Area (MTMC) for transport of a quantity of fuel.

We dismiss the protest because the matter is outside our bid protest jurisdiction.

Staff contends that while its bid for transporting the fuel was higher than that of Gulf Intercoastal Marine, the awardee, it should have received the award because it could have performed the work sooner than the awardee and bids were requested on an "as soon as possible" basis.

MTMC is the agency responsible for the direction, control and supervision of all functions incident to the acquisition and use of freight transportation services for the Department of Defense (DOD) from commercial transportation companies. MTMC acquires its transportation services pursuant to the Defense Traffic Management Regulation, which provides for MTMC authority over DOD transportation, and the MTMC Inland Freight Traffic Regulation (MTMCR) 55-1 which governs negotiations for commercial transportation, tariffs, tenders, rates and routings. See Federal Transport, Inc.-- Request for Recon., 68 Comp.Gen. 451 (1989), 89-1 CPD Para. 542.

According to the agency, the procurement at issue here is a "spot movement negotiation" for a "spot movement" which is defined as a one time shipment of a commodity on one bill of lading which requires special equipment or service not otherwise provided by tariff or special rate tender. MTMCR 55-1, Sec. 2-2.2. That regulation further provides that "area commanders will solicit tenders from all carriers who possess the necessary operating authorities to perform the services required." MTMCR 55-1, Sec. 2-2.2.

While we do assert jurisdiction over protests concernin requests for tenders issued under MTMC's guaranteed traffic program, we do not do so under the spot bid procedures used here. Moody Bros. of Jacksonville, Inc.; Troika International Ltd., June 12, 1990, 90-1 CPD Para. ***. We do not consider protests under the spot bid procedures. These procedures contemplate an informal acquisition resulting in a one time government bill of lading shipment; no formal solicitation is issued and no source selection is conducted. Id.

We dismiss the protest.

Mar 22, 2018

Mar 20, 2018

Mar 19, 2018

  • Ampcus, Inc.
    We deny the protest.
  • AMAR Health IT, LLC
    We dismiss the protest because our Office does not have jurisdiction to entertain protests of task orders issued under civilian agency multiple-award, indefinite-delivery, indefinite-quantity (IDIQ) contracts that are valued at less than $10 million.
  • Centurum, Inc.--Costs
    We grant the request.

Mar 15, 2018

  • ORBIS Sibro, Inc.
    We sustain the protest in part and deny it in part.

Mar 14, 2018

Mar 13, 2018

  • Interoperability Clearinghouse
    We dismiss the protest because the protester, a not-for-profit entity, is not an interested party to challenge this sole-source award to an Alaska Native Corporation under the Small Business Administration's (SBA) 8(a) program.

Looking for more? Browse all our products here