https://www.gao.gov/products/139597

B-235647: Sep 21, 1989

A firm protested a Navy contract award for integrated logistics support services, contending that the Navy: (1) evaluators did not base their proposal ratings on objective standards; (2) improperly afforded more weight to the most important evaluation criterion, since its unacceptable rating in only that area caused the overall unacceptable rating; and (3) did not conduct meaningful discussions. G...

https://www.gao.gov/products/474436

B-235647: Sep 21, 1989

Where the offeror was twice apprised of which task responses were unacceptable and the offeror's protest of the evaluation constitutes a mere disagreement with the agency evaluation. 2. Disparities in evaluation ratings among technical evaluators do not establish an award decision was not rationally based in view of the potential for disparate subjective judgments of different evaluators on the re...