More Planning Needed to Support Future Needs for Electric Power in Space
RCED-94-6, Oct 7, 1993
Pursuant to a congressional request, GAO reviewed the Department of Energy's (DOE) plans for radioisotope thermoelectric generator (RTG) assembly operations, focusing on: (1) where DOE plans to assemble RTG in the future; (2) the cost to overhaul the Mound facility to make it suitable for long-term RTG assembly operations; (3) how DOE will address public safety concerns about maintaining nuclear operations in a residential area; and (4) DOE expenditures to modify the Hanford facility in preparation of RTG assembly.
GAO found that: (1) DOE plans to continue RTG assembly and testing at its Mound facility through the completion of the National Aeronautics and Space Administration's (NASA) Cassini mission in October 1997, but it has not developed a plan for reliable, uninterrupted RTG support after the Cassini mission; (2) DOE has cancelled its Hanford RTG project because it plans to keep long-term RTG support at the Mound facility, but the plant may be closed under DOE consolidation plans; (3) DOE believes Mound RTG operations will be less expensive than completing the new Hanford facility, since the Air Force cancelled its RTG requirements; (4) DOE does not want to introduce new RTG operations at the Hanford facility because it is in the cleanup-and-restoration stage of its life cycle; (5) DOE has not estimated the cost of long-term RTG operations at its Mound facility; (6) DOE believes that RTG operations at the Mound facility do not pose a nuclear hazard problem for the residential area, since the nuclear material used will be encapsulated; and (7) DOE has spent $25.7 million on the Hanford facility and estimates it will cost an additional $24.2 million to complete the project by September 1995.
- Closed - implemented
- Closed - not implemented
Recommendation for Executive Action
Recommendation: To ensure that an RTG infrastructure will be in place to meet requirements after the 1997 Cassini mission, the Secretary of Energy should direct DOE planners to develop a plan for RTG support. The plan should include the validated cost of modifications needed to ensure that the Mound RTG operations can effectively support NASA and Department of Defense long-term RTG requirements. The plan should also include arrangements that ensure uninterrupted support of these long-term RTG requirements if the Mound facility is unable to perform this function.
Agency Affected: Department of Energy
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: DOE's draft plan has been in review status for almost 2 years and it appears that DOE's Office of Nuclear Energy has no intention of finalizing the plan.