Consumer Product Safety Commission:

Concerns About Staff Memorandum Relating to All-Terrain Vehicles

HRD-87-7: Published: Nov 7, 1986. Publicly Released: Nov 7, 1986.

Contact:

Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov

In response to a congressional request, GAO reviewed a Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) staff memorandum containing comparative injury data for all-terrain vehicles (ATV), minibikes, and snowmobiles to determine: (1) the source and reliability of the vehicle usage data the memorandum presented; (2) whether its conclusions were justified; (3) why CPSC prepared it; and (4) whether its preparation was consistent with CPSC procedures.

GAO found that: (1) prior CPSC information indicated that ATV posed a greater consumer hazard than did minibikes and snowmobiles; (2) CPSC based this information on a comparative-injury analysis that did not consider the relative usage patterns of the three vehicles; (3) by contrast, the memorandum's comparative-injury analysis indicated that, based on an approximation of vehicle usage patterns, ATV posed no greater hazard to consumers than the other two vehicles; (4) the reliability of the memorandum's usage data was questionable because it was based on unsubstantiated anecdotal information from a small number of witnesses at CPSC public hearings on ATV; (5) CPSC officials believed that the earlier analysis incorrectly implied that ATV were more hazardous than minibikes and snowmobiles; (6) CPSC preparation of an adjusted analysis may have been inconsistent with the commissioners' intention to limit a staff analysis to ATV, as the other vehicles were not a regulatory concern at that time; and (7) CPSC restricted public dissemination of the memorandum pending further consideration.

Apr 7, 2014

Mar 28, 2014

Feb 25, 2014

Feb 13, 2014

Jan 16, 2014

Jan 6, 2014

Dec 18, 2013

Dec 11, 2013

Nov 26, 2013

Looking for more? Browse all our products here