Skip to main content

Small Business Research Programs: Agencies Have Improved Compliance with Spending and Reporting Requirements, but Challenges Remain

GAO-16-492 Published: May 26, 2016. Publicly Released: May 26, 2016.
Jump To:
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

What GAO Found

Agency data indicate that 9 of the 11 agencies participating in the Small Business Innovation Research (SBIR) program and 4 of the 5 agencies participating in the Small Business Technology Transfer (STTR) program complied with spending requirements in fiscal year 2014. One agency—the Department of Agriculture (USDA)—had extramural R&D obligations greater than $1 billion, but did not implement an STTR program, as required in the Small Business Act. This is, in part, because the Small Business Administration's (SBA) guidance does not address when an agency should establish a new STTR program. As a result, in fiscal year 2014, less money was available for awards to small businesses through this program.

Most participating agencies did not fully comply with certain reporting requirements. For example, while all participating agencies submitted the required methodology reports for fiscal year 2014, 6 of the 11 did not fully itemize the specific programs they excluded from their extramural R&D, did not fully explain the reasons why they excluded the programs, or both. Additionally, 2 agencies did not submit complete information on the dollar amounts of exclusions in fiscal year 2014 because of a change in SBA's fiscal year 2014 guidance. Restoring this guidance could provide information to help SBA assess the accuracy of agency methodology reports.

GAO's analysis shows that basing SBIR and STTR spending requirements on an agency's total R&D budget authority instead of its extramural R&D obligations could increase the amount each agency has to spend on the programs and increase the number of agencies required to participate in the programs. Some agency officials identified benefits of this potential change, such as more funding to make awards to small businesses, but some agencies identified drawbacks, such as limiting resources for other R&D programs.

Total administrative spending on the SBIR and STTR programs in fiscal year 2014 is unknown, but agencies participating in the administrative pilot program spent about $19 million on new activities. Agencies do not and are not required to track total administrative costs, and therefore total spending could not be calculated for fiscal year 2014. Seven agencies participated in the administrative pilot program and tracked the amounts of program funds they spent on new administrative and oversight activities in fiscal year 2014. While these 7 agencies spent more on the program in fiscal year 2014 than in the previous year, some of these agencies identified constraints that limited their participation. For example, agency officials pointed to guidance that requires agencies to only spend money on new initiatives and the limited length of the pilot. Agency officials told GAO these constraints kept them from achieving program goals by preventing them from undertaking some initiatives and hiring individuals for administrative purposes. SBA plans to include its required evaluation of the pilot program in its annual report to Congress, which could include an evaluation of such constraints and the steps needed to address them, but it has not yet submitted its fiscal year 2014 report to Congress. Until SBA submits its evaluation of the pilot program, SBA and Congress will not have needed information about the pilot for fiscal year 2014 or potential constraints for participants.

Why GAO Did This Study

Federal agencies have awarded contracts and grants totaling more than $40 billion through the SBIR and STTR programs to small businesses to develop and commercialize innovative technologies. The Small Business Act requires agencies with extramural R&D obligations that meet certain thresholds—$100 million for SBIR and $1 billion for STTR—to spend a percentage of these funds on the programs. The agencies are to report on their activities to SBA, and in turn, SBA is to report to Congress.

The 2011 reauthorization of the programs includes a provision for GAO to review compliance with spending and reporting requirements and other program aspects. This report examines, for fiscal year 2014, (1) the extent to which participating agencies complied with spending requirements, (2) the extent to which agencies and SBA complied with certain reporting requirements, (3) the potential effects of basing spending requirements on total R&D budget authority, and (4) what is known about the amounts spent to administer the programs. GAO reviewed agency spending data and reports and interviewed program officials from SBA and the 11 participating agencies.

Recommendations

GAO recommends that SBA clarify guidance for when an agency is to start up an STTR program, restore guidance about dollar amounts of exclusions in the methodology report, and complete the required report to Congress for fiscal year 2014.

SBA generally agreed with GAO's findings and recommendations.

Recommendations for Executive Action

Agency Affected Recommendation Status
Small Business Administration To ensure full compliance with SBIR and STTR spending and reporting requirements and improve participation in the administrative pilot program, the SBA Administrator should review SBA guidance regarding when an agency is required to start up an SBIR or STTR program, and if necessary, update the guidance to provide greater clarity to agencies with research or research and development (R&D) obligations greater than the thresholds for participating.
Closed – Implemented
In April 2019, SBA issued updated policy directives for the SBIR and STTR programs that included additional information on when a federal agency is required to start an SBIR or STTR program. Specifically, the revised policy directive--effective May 2, 2019--clarifies that agencies with an extramural research or research and development budget that exceeds the minimum for participating in the programs based on 3-year forecasts as found in the annual Budget of the United States Government and the National Science Foundation's Survey of Federal Funds for Research and Development should begin participating in the programs.
Small Business Administration To ensure full compliance with SBIR and STTR spending and reporting requirements and improve participation in the administrative pilot program, the SBA Administrator should restore guidance requesting that agencies provide dollar amounts for exclusions in agency methodology reports to SBA.
Closed – Implemented
SBA officials updated the template that the participating agencies used to report information to SBA for fiscal year 2016, which was submitted in March 2017. The revised template restored the guidance to collect the dollar amounts associated with programs exempted and excluded from the calculation of extramural research or research and development.
Small Business Administration To ensure full compliance with SBIR and STTR spending and reporting requirements and improve participation in the administrative pilot program, the SBA Administrator should complete the required reporting on the administrative pilot program for fiscal year 2014, which could include an evaluation of the potential constraints that may hinder agencies' participation and any steps to address these constraints.
Closed – Implemented
SBA reported information on agencies' use of the administrative pilot program in its annual reports to Congress for fiscal years 2014, 2015, and 2016. Those reports described the amounts obligated through the administrative pilot program and examples of how the agencies used their funds obligated for the program. These reports did not include information on potential constraints that could hinder agencies participating in the program or steps to address the constraints. Because that information is not required to be reported to Congress, we believe SBA's reporting meets the reporting requirement.

Full Report

GAO Contacts

Office of Public Affairs

Topics

Budget authorityBudget outlaysCost analysisFederal agenciesReporting requirementsResearch and developmentResearch programsSmall businessSmall business assistanceTechnological innovationsComplianceProgram goals or objectives