Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act:
Procedures for Reporting Certain Financial Management Information Should Be Improved
GAO-14-697: Published: Sep 22, 2014. Publicly Released: Sep 22, 2014.
What GAO Found
The Department of Health and Human Service's (HHS) Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) provided GAO with most of the requested data regarding financial resources that the Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight (CCIIO) and other CMS offices received, used, and expect to use to implement the private health insurance and health insurance exchange provisions of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) for which CCIIO is responsible from its enactment in March 2010 through fiscal year 2014. However, CMS did not provide estimates of fiscal year 2014 obligations for certain categories of CCIIO-related transactions, such as advertising and other public relations activities. In addition, CMS provided data on CCIIO's staffing levels as of September 30, 2013, but did not provide complete staffing reassignment data.
GAO was unable to consistently verify the reliability of the data received from CMS. Specifically:
GAO was able to determine the reliability of CMS's estimates for total obligations for fiscal year 2014, which was $3.7 billion; the number of staff as of September 30, 2013, which was 347; and total salary expenditures from March 2010 through fiscal year 2013, which were $79.8 million.
GAO could not determine the reliability of any of the other financial information CMS provided because CMS's core financial system did not produce totals for much of the CCIIO-related information requested. For example, the system did not produce expenditure totals for CCIIO-related polling, focus groups, or advertising and other public relations activities because of how these activities are captured in the system. Similarly, information related to reassignment of staff to CCIIO from other CMS and HHS units was not readily available. Consequently, the staff reassignment information provided to GAO was not complete, was not supported by documentary evidence, and could not be verified.
GAO identified several issues that contributed to CMS's inability to provide complete information that is independently verifiable in a timely manner. First, CMS does not have an effective means of identifying CCIIO-related information. While CMS had policies and procedures for its standard financial operations, it did not have documented policies and procedures for responding to nonroutine information requests. Instead, CMS relied on ad hoc manual procedures that were labor intensive and time consuming. As a result, CMS required an extended period of time to provide most of the information GAO requested, in some cases taking several months. Second, CMS does not have documented procedures to ensure that data requests are reviewed and approved for accuracy. CMS officials told GAO that the information they provided had been subject to review and approval at several levels, including review by subject matter experts. However, these procedures were not documented. Consequently, GAO was not able to independently verify that they had been properly performed. Because CMS's processes are inconsistent with certain federal accounting and internal control standards, Congress and other decision makers may not have access to timely and reliable CCIIO-related information that they may need to make resource allocation decisions and assessments of program performance.
Why GAO Did This Study
PPACA makes significant changes in the way health insurance in the United States is provided, including changes to private health insurance coverage. GAO was asked to examine the resources that CCIIO used and expects to use in implementing the private health insurance provisions of PPACA. GAO's objective was to identify resources that CCIIO received, used, and expects to use from enactment of PPACA through fiscal year 2014, including certain categories of expenditures, the sources of funding, and the total number of staff, along with the number of staff reassigned from other units.
To perform this work GAO obtained the information requested and compared it to available supporting documentation, reviewed available related policies and procedures, and interviewed CMS officials.
What GAO Recommends
GAO recommends that CMS identify and evaluate options to facilitate reporting CCIIO-related financial management information that is independently verifiable in a timely manner, and develop and implement policies and procedures to document the preparation, review, and approval of information produced for nonroutine requests.
HHS did not concur with GAO's recommendations. In its view, CMS's existing procedures are adequate to respond to nonroutine information requests. However, as discussed in this report, GAO continues to believe that enhancements to CMS's procedures are needed and that the recommendations are valid.
For more information, contact Beryl H. Davis at (202) 512-2623 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Recommendations for Executive Action
Comments: The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) disagreed with this recommendation. HHS management indicated that it has up-to-date and clearly documented standard operating procedures (SOP) for its normal day-to-day work processes, and did not believe that non-standard data requests lend themselves to documented, standard SOPs. In May 2016, HHS indicated that its position on this issue has not changed. In June 2017, HHS indicated that its position on this issue has not changed. GAO believes the recommendation is still valid.
Recommendation: The Secretary of Health and Human Services should direct the Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to develop and implement policies and procedures for responding to nonroutine CCIIO-related financial management information requests, including procedures for documenting the preparation process and the review and approval of the results.
Agency Affected: Department of Health and Human Services
Comments: The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) disagreed with this recommendation. HHS indicated that it tracks appropriations in accordance with all relevant federal laws and regulations, and that the information was complete and verifiable. Federal accounting concepts and standards concerning managerial cost accounting allow flexibility for agency managers to develop costing methods that are best suited to their operational environment. HHS indicated that would continue to evaluate options of enhancing the standard and/or custom reporting capabilities of its core financial system; the Health Integrated General Ledger System (HIGLAS). In May 2016, HHS indicated that its position on this issue has not changed. In June 2017, HHS indicated that its position on this issue has not changed. GAO believes the recommendation is still valid.
Recommendation: The Secretary of Health and Human Services should direct the Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to identify and evaluate options to facilitate more timely and independently verifiable reporting of CCIIO-related financial management information, such as enhancing Healthcare Integrated General Ledger Accounting System's standard reporting or custom reporting capabilities.
Agency Affected: Department of Health and Human Services