Unemployed Older Workers:
Many Experience Challenges Regaining Employment and Face Reduced Retirement Security
GAO-12-445: Published: Apr 25, 2012. Publicly Released: May 15, 2012.
- VIDEO: Examples of Financial and Reemployment Challenges Long-Term Unemployed Older Workers Face
This video contains excerpts from focus groups GAO conducted with long-term unemployed older workers discussing the challenges they face in unemployment and how it has affected their plans for retirement.
What GAO Found
As with many other demographic groups, older workers unemployment overall and long-term unemployment rates have increased dramatically since the recession began in 2007. In December 2011, the unemployment rate for older workers was 6.0 percent, up from 3.1 at the start of the recession, but down from its peak of 7.6 percent in February 2010. In particular, long-term unemployment rose substantially, and at a greater rate for older than younger workers. By 2011, 55 percent of unemployed older workers had been actively seeking a job for more than half a year (27 weeks or more). Meanwhile, the long-term trend of rising labor force participation rates among older workers has continued, with the recession possibly amplifying this trend.
Long-term unemployment can put older workers at risk of deferring needed medical care, losing their homes, and accumulating debt. The experts and staff GAO interviewed at some one-stop career centers, as well as the unemployed older workers who participated in GAOs focus groups, identified employer reluctance to hire older workers as a key challenge that older workers face in finding reemployment. They also identified out-of-date skills, discouragement and depression, and inexperience with online applications as reemployment barriers for older workers. Some one-stop staff who serve older workers told GAO that providing the type of assistance some older workers need to address these unique challenges can be very time-consuming. (For audio clips from GAOs focus groups with unemployed older workers, use this link: http://www.gao.gov/multimedia/video/#video_id=590295)
Long-term unemployment can substantially diminish an older workers future retirement income in several ways. First, it can force a worker to stop working and stop saving for retirement earlier than the worker had planned. Second, long-term unemployment can lead individuals to draw down their retirement savings to cover living expenses while they are unemployed, which was a common life experience described by GAOs focus group participants. GAO illustrated how a hypothetical worker who had $70,000 in retirement savings at age 55 and withdrew 50 percent of those savings during a 2 year period of unemployment, would need about another 5 ½ years of work and saving to rebuild the retirement account to the level it had been before unemployment began. In addition, long-term unemployment can motivate older workers to claim early Social Security retirement benefits, which will result in lower monthly benefits for workers and their survivors for the rest of their lives.
Experts GAO interviewed selected various policies that have been proposed to help address unemployed older workers reemployment challenges. Experts selected these policies from a broad list GAO compiled from previous academic studies. For example, two of the policies that experts selected would provide incentives such as temporary wage or training subsidies for employers to hire long-term unemployed older workers. In the current context of high unemployment and slow job creation, the impact of most of these policies is likely to be muted by limited job openings. After an interagency Taskforce issued its report on the aging of the American workforce in 2008, Labor implemented several strategies the report recommended, but since the recession started, Labor shifted focus to responding to increased demand for services. As the economy improves, Labor could refocus on older job seekers and consider what additional strategies would help address their unique reemployment challenges, in light of recent economic and technological changes.
Why GAO Did This Study
The number of workers age 55 and over experiencing long-term unemployment has grown substantially since the recession began in 2007. This raises concerns about how long-term unemployment will affect older workers reemployment prospects and future retirement income.
In light of these developments, GAO examined (1) how older workers employment status has changed since the recession, (2) what risks unemployed older workers face and what challenges they experience in finding reemployment, (3) how long-term unemployment could affect older workers retirement income, and (4) what other policies might help them return to work and what steps the Department of Labor (Labor) has taken to help unemployed older workers.
To conduct this work, GAO analyzed nationally representative datasets, led focus groups of unemployed older workers, modeled how job loss affects retirement income, and interviewed experts and federal and local officials.
What GAO Recommends
To foster the employment of older workers, we recommend that the Secretary of Labor consider what strategies are needed to address the unique needs of older job seekers, in light of recent economic and technological changes.
Labor agreed with our recommendation. GAO received technical comments on a draft of this report from Labor and the Social Security Administration, and incorporated them as appropriate.
For more information, contact Charlie Jeszeck at (202) 512-7215 firstname.lastname@example.org.
Recommendation for Executive Action
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: The Department of Labor (Labor) has considered strategies to address the unique needs of older job seekers. In 2014, Labor's Employment and Training Administration (ETA) reported that ETA and the Office of Disability Employment Policy (ODEP) held a webinar and a series of consultation calls in Spring 2014 with stakeholders, including states and senior-serving organizations, on guiding principles for a revision to the Older Worker Protocol. ETA focused on improved services to older workers in its competitive grants. ETA awarded nearly $170 million Ready To Work grants in October 2014 to 23 partnerships providing services in 20 states and Puerto Rico. The grants primarily focused on helping those experiencing long-term unemployment find jobs, through training and supportive and specialized services leading to rapid employment in middle- and high-skilled jobs. The funding opportunity announcement highlighted that unemployed older workers are more likely to remain unemployed longer than those in other age groups and likely to represent a significant portion of those long-term unemployed individuals served through the Ready To Work grants. As a result, certain Ready to Work grants actively target older workers, such as the Anne Arundel Workforce Development Corporation (AAWDC) in Maryland. AAWDC has partnered with the AARP Foundation to reach out to individuals over 50 through their BACK TO WORK 50+ initiative. AARP Foundation will lead outreach activities to individuals over 50 through co-branded marketing, a toll-free number, and a trained professional call center to reach older workers experiencing long-term unemployment or who have dropped out of the labor force. Further, ETA awarded a contract in May 2014 to build upon existing training modules for frontline workforce system staff that focus on various topics related to adapting services for an aging population, including intergenerational communication, aging in the workplace, and accommodations that assist older workers in remaining in or reentering the workforce (such as flexible work arrangements or adaptive technology). Finally, ETA issued guidance that highlights examples of strategies used to address the unique needs of older job seekers. Specifically, ETA issued Training and Employment Guidance Letter (TEGL) 04-15, Vision for the One-Stop Delivery System in August 2015. The guidance includes extensive discussion of one-stop service accessibility, and includes a link to a toolkit that includes content contributed by ETA's Older Workers Program entitled "Opening Doors for Everyone: Providing Outstanding Customer Service at One-Stop Career Centers" (https://wioa.workforce3one.org/view/2001501480321360042/info).
Recommendation: To foster the employment of older workers, the Secretary of Labor should consider what strategies are needed to address the unique needs of older job seekers, in light of recent economic and technological changes.
Agency Affected: Department of Labor