IRS May Be Able to Improve Compliance for Nonresident Aliens and Updating Requirements Could Reduce Their Compliance Burden
GAO-10-429: Published: Apr 14, 2010. Publicly Released: May 14, 2010.
What GAO Found
For tax year 2007, nonresident alien individuals filed about 634,000 Forms 1040NR, the U.S. Nonresident Alien Income Tax Return. IRS has not developed estimates for the extent of nonresident alien tax noncompliance because it often lacks information to distinguish between nonresident aliens and other filers, and examinations can be costly and difficult since many nonresident aliens would depart the country before IRS could examine their returns. IRS's outreach and education efforts have focused on presenting information on nonresident tax issues to a variety of audiences and making information available on its Web site and in its publications. Nevertheless, some nonresidents, their employers, and paid preparers may not be aware of nonresident alien tax rules, according to representatives of groups that work with employers and nonresidents to assist them in fulfilling their tax obligations. Other filing challenges exist. For example, individuals filing Forms 1040NR cannot file electronically. Also, nonresidents in the U.S. for less than 90 days who earn over $3,000 in compensation for services paid for by a foreign employer will likely have to file Form 1040NR, even if they owe no tax. The $3,000 exemption threshold, enacted by Congress in 1936 to lessen the tax compliance burden on nonresident aliens and never adjusted for inflation or other purposes, likely results in a greater proportion of nonresident aliens having a filing requirement today than in 1936. IRS has expanded its nonresident alien enforcement efforts over the past decade. However, IRS does not have a program to automatically identify nonresident aliens who improperly file Form 1040 instead of Form 1040NR, which can result in lost tax revenue when these taxpayers take unallowed deductions. IRS may be able to use taxpayer information to identify this type of noncompliance systematically. Finally, some nonresidents must file a certificate of compliance, referred to as a sailing permit, before departing the U.S. to ensure that tax obligations have been satisfied. The requirement is difficult to enforce and few nonresidents fulfill it, potentially leading to broader noncompliance if individuals assume the lack of enforcement extends to other tax rules.
Why GAO Did This Study
Every year, the U.S. receives millions of legal visits by foreign individuals. Nonresident aliens--who are neither U.S. citizens nor residents--may be required to file a federal tax return if they earn U.S.- source income, and their noncompliance can contribute to the tax gap. As with U.S. citizens and residents, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) is responsible for ensuring that nonresident aliens fulfill their tax obligations. GAO was asked to (1) identify what data are available on nonresident alien tax filing and compliance, (2) provide information on guidance IRS provides to nonresident aliens and third parties on tax requirements and any challenges associated with filing, and (3) assess actions IRS takes to enforce nonresident alien tax compliance. To meet its objectives, GAO examined IRS and other federal agency documentation, reviewed tax filing and other data, and interviewed IRS officials and other third parties.
What GAO Recommends
GAO suggests that Congress consider raising the exemption threshold for income paid by a foreign employer and eliminating the certificate of compliance, or sailing permit, requirement. GAO also recommends that IRS determine if creating an automated program to identify improper filing of Form 1040 by nonresident aliens would be a cost-effective means of improving compliance. In commenting on a draft of this report, IRS agreed with our recommendation.
Matters for Congressional Consideration
Comments: As of November 2015, Congress had not raised the amount of U.S. income paid by a foreign employer that is exempt from tax for nonresidents who meet the other conditions of the exemption.
Matter: Given the increasing extent of business travel to the U.S. and the eroding effect of inflation, Congress may wish to consider raising the amount of U.S. income paid by a foreign employer that is exempt from tax for nonresidents who meet the other conditions of the exemption.
Comments: As of November 2015, Congress has not eliminated the sailing permit requirement.
Matter: Given the difficulty of enforcing the requirement for aliens to obtain certificates of compliance--sailing permits--before departing the country and the existence of withholding requirements and tax treaties, Congress may wish to consider eliminating the sailing permit requirement.
Recommendation for Executive Action
Status: Closed - Implemented
Comments: IRS performed a study to determine the effectiveness and feasibility of establishing an automated program to identify improper filing of Form 1040 by nonresident aliens. IRS concluded that establishing an automated program to identify such improper filings is not cost-effective at this time because of the limited information available to systematically make such determinations, and the low potential for increased tax results.
Recommendation: The Commissioner of Internal Revenue should determine if creating an automated program to identify nonresident aliens who may have improperly filed Form 1040 instead of Form 1040NR by using ITIN information would be a cost-effective means to improve compliance.
Agency Affected: Department of the Treasury: Internal Revenue Service