Taxpayer Information:

Options Exist to Enable Data Sharing Between IRS and USCIS but Each Presents Challenges

GAO-06-100: Published: Oct 11, 2005. Publicly Released: Nov 14, 2005.

Additional Materials:

Contact:

Michael Brostek
(202) 512-9039
contact@gao.gov

 

Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov

In 2000, federal agencies estimated they saved at least $900 million annually through data sharing initiatives. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) can use data from taxpayers and third parties to better ensure taxpayers meet their obligations. Likewise, Congress has authorized certain agencies access to taxpayer information collected by IRS to better determine benefit eligibility. In July 2004, we reported that data sharing between IRS and the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has the potential to improve tax compliance as well as immigration eligibility decisions (GAO-04-972T). For this report, GAO determined (1) the potential benefits of data matching, and (2) the options and associated challenges.

Data sharing can help improve (1) tax compliance if businesses applying to sponsor immigrant workers are required to meet tax filing and payment requirements, and (2) the accuracy and timeliness of USCIS's immigration eligibility decisions if it obtained tax data from IRS to help ensure business sponsors meet eligibility criteria. As of December 2003, IRS databases showed 18,942 businesses (5 percent) applying to sponsor immigrant workers had $5.6 billion in unpaid assessments. Of this amount, businesses were not in installment agreements with IRS or otherwise making payments on $3.7 billion. If future business sponsors owe taxes and are required to meet their tax obligations, they would need to make arrangements with the IRS to come into compliance. Although USCIS officials acknowledge that no explicit prohibition exists in immigration laws against conditioning approval of employer applications on their tax compliance, USCIS officials said a statutory change is preferable because they have legal concerns about USCIS's authority to issue such a regulation absent specific authority. IRS data can help USCIS make more accurate eligibility decisions by better identifying businesses that may not have met eligibility criteria due to having unpaid assessments or not filing returns. In our nationwide selection, 67,949 of 413,723 (16 percent) business sponsors were in IRS's nonfiler database at the time of their application. A variety of options is available to IRS and USCIS for establishing and implementing data sharing. An applicant-initiated data-sharing arrangement could be implemented under existing Internal Revenue Code authority through taxpayer consent, whereby taxpayers authorize IRS to disclose their information. USCIS then could verify applicant-provided data by obtaining tax returns or tax transcripts. Treasury guidance suggests a small-scale pilot using consents as a way to make the business case for continued access to taxpayer information. In general, the more that data sharing could be done electronically, the more efficient the data sharing could be. However, achieving electronic data sharing may take longer than paper-based processes due to legal, technological, and cost challenges. Further, if business sponsors need to come into compliance, net tax collections might not increase if collecting their taxes displaces other IRS work. Establishing user fees to cover data-sharing costs could be a way to fund data sharing, but IRS lacks the authority to collect and retain a user fee to cover compliance-related costs associated with data sharing.

Matters for Congressional Consideration

  1. Status: Closed - Not Implemented

    Comments: No legislative changes have been made. On 9/15/09, USCIS said they have abandoned any work on the recommended pilot project, due to many management concerns, including public relations issues.

    Matter: To improve taxpayer compliance and USCIS's immigration benefit decisions, Congress may wish to consider changing immigration eligibility to require businesses applying to sponsor immigrant workers to meet tax filing and payment obligations to sponsor immigrant workers.

  2. Status: Closed - Not Implemented

    Comments: No legislative changes have been made. On 09/15/2009, USCIS said they have abandoned any work on the recommended pilot project, due to many management concerns, including public relations issues.

    Matter: To improve taxpayer compliance and USCIS's immigration benefit decisions, Congress may wish to consider authorizing a user fee to be collected and retained by IRS to cover the costs of bringing non-compliant taxpayers into compliance.

Recommendation for Executive Action

  1. Status: Closed - Not Implemented

    Comments: On 9/15/09, USCIS via email said USCIS has abandoned any work on the recommended pilot project, due to many management concerns, including public relations issues.

    Recommendation: To improve the accuracy and timeliness of USCIS's immigration eligibility decisions absent requiring businesses to have met their tax filing and payment obligations, the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security should direct USCIS, in consultation with the IRS, to conduct a pilot data-sharing test. In the test, USCIS should require a tax check for selected businesses and other entities applying to sponsor immigrant workers before qualifying for immigration benefits. The pilot test should assess and document the costs and benefits of data sharing including key issues such as using paper or electronic consents, or pursuing specific IRC Section 6103 disclosure authority, assessing resource implications, and considering how the agencies would allocate responsibilities for collecting and allocating user fees from the business sponsors.

    Agency Affected: Department of Homeland Security: United States Citizenship and Immigration Services

 

Explore the full database of GAO's Open Recommendations »

Aug 1, 2014

Jul 23, 2014

Jul 8, 2014

Dec 5, 2013

Sep 10, 2013

Aug 22, 2013

Jun 20, 2013

May 9, 2013

Apr 4, 2013

Looking for more? Browse all our products here