Uncertainties About the Effectiveness of Federal Programs To Make New Buildings More Energy Efficient
EMD-80-32: Published: Jan 28, 1980. Publicly Released: Jan 28, 1980.
- Full Report:
An evaluation is reported of the states' progress in developing and implementing thermal efficiency standards for new buildings as part of the State Energy Conservation Program. Issues are discussed which may impede the timely and effective implementation of building energy performance standards currently being developed by the Department of Energy (DOE). The State Energy Conservation program provides for each state to establish a number of conservation programs, including building standards stressing thermal efficiency, to achieve state conservation goals. The Energy Performance Standards for New Buildings Program will govern the design and construction of new commercial and residential buildings to achieve the maximum number of practical improvements in energy efficiency and to increase the use of nondepletable energy in new buildings.
The effectiveness of the State Energy Conservation Program is uncertain. Many states had not implemented thermal efficiency standards by the DOE target date of January 1, 1978. These delays could reduce the projected 1980 energy savings by the equivalent of about 46,000 barrels of oil per day. About 41 states had adopted some type of thermal efficiency standards by September 1979. In some of these states, standards: have not been established for all building categories, are not mandatory for all new construction, or are not mandatory in all jurisdictions of the state. Because DOE has not consistently applied the compliance criteria it has developed to all states, compliance with the law or DOE regulations has not been assured. The implementation of the Building Energy Performance Standards Program can be expedited if states and local governments have fully implemented thermal efficiency standards before the performance standards become effective. Because many state and local governments have not yet adopted thermal efficiency standards, most states do not know which building standards local governments have adopted and if or how local governments are enforcing state standards. In this situation, states will not be able to certify that all jurisdictions have adopted and are enforcing building codes consistent with the performance standards, when they become effective.
Recommendation for Executive Action
Comments: Please call 202/512-6100 for additional information.
Recommendation: With respect to the State Energy Conservation Program, the Secretary of Energy should assess the way state compliance with program requirements for fiscal year 1979 was determined. If any state is determined not to be in full compliance, the Secretary should consider granting more time for such a state to comply. With respect to the building energy performance standards program, the Secretary should: continue to work with the states and/or local jurisdictions to assist them in adopting and enforcing thermal efficiency standards, even if the statutory authorization for the State Energy Conservation Program expires; work jointly with the states to monitor local jurisdictions' standards implementation activities, so that states will have a reliable basis for certifying compliance with the building energy performance standards, when promulgated; and develop and implement a management system providing a database for effectively evaluating the program when implemented.