Skip to main content

[Requests for Reconsideration of Sustained Protest of Air Force Procurement]

B-253278.3,B-253278.4,B-253278.5 Published: Apr 07, 1994. Publicly Released: Apr 07, 1994.
Jump To:
Skip to Highlights

Highlights

The Air Force, the Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA), and a firm requested reconsideration of the firm's sustained protest against an Air Force work assignment for the repair and overhaul of aircraft landing gear. GAO had held that: (1) DCAA unreasonably certified the awardee's proposed costs; and (2) the Air Force should terminate the work assignment and make award to the protester. In their requests for reconsideration, the Air Force and DCAA contended that: (1) DCAA did not have certifying authority and the Air Force was not bound by DCAA findings; (2) GAO did not have authority to review DCAA actions; (3) GAO improperly considered an audit report in making its decision; and (4) GAO improperly recommended that award be made to the protester prior to DCAA certification. GAO held that: (1) the legislation removing DCAA certifying authority was enacted after the current procurement; (2) under the applicable law, DCAA was required to certify government bids and the Air Force was required to accept its decision; (3) GAO had specific authority to decide bid protests involving procurement statutes; (4) DCAA unreasonably certified the awardee's costs contrary to its own finding that the awardee's costs were understated; (5) DCAA certification of the protester's costs was a mere formality, since the award was for a firm, fixed-price contract; and (6) it would not consider the protester's reconsideration request, since it was not altering its original decision. Accordingly, the original decision was affirmed.

Office of Public Affairs

Topics

Air Force procurementBid evaluation protestsBid protest reconsiderationsContract award protestsContract costsCost analysisImproper award of contractJurisdictional authorityQuestionable procurement chargesRepair contractsBid proposalsU.S. Air ForceOverhead costsAudit reportsSolicitations