This is the accessible text file for GAO report number GAO-12-264 entitled 'DHS Human Capital: Senior Leadership Vacancy Rates Generally Declined, but Components' Rates Varied' which was released on February 10, 2012. This text file was formatted by the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) to be accessible to users with visual impairments, as part of a longer term project to improve GAO products' accessibility. Every attempt has been made to maintain the structural and data integrity of the original printed product. Accessibility features, such as text descriptions of tables, consecutively numbered footnotes placed at the end of the file, and the text of agency comment letters, are provided but may not exactly duplicate the presentation or format of the printed version. The portable document format (PDF) file is an exact electronic replica of the printed version. We welcome your feedback. Please E-mail your comments regarding the contents or accessibility features of this document to Webmaster@gao.gov. This is a work of the U.S. government and is not subject to copyright protection in the United States. It may be reproduced and distributed in its entirety without further permission from GAO. Because this work may contain copyrighted images or other material, permission from the copyright holder may be necessary if you wish to reproduce this material separately. United States Government Accountability Office: GAO: Report to Congressional Committees: February 2012: DHS Human Capital: Senior Leadership Vacancy Rates Generally Declined, but Components' Rates Varied: GAO-12-264: GAO Highlights: Highlights of GAO-12-264, a report to congressional committees. Why GAO Did This Study: Since its creation, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has faced scrutiny from Congress and others concerning DHS’s ability to hire and retain senior executives. GAO was requested to review senior leadership vacancies at DHS, including efforts to address vacancies. This report addresses: (1) vacancy rates in DHS senior leadership positions from fiscal years 2006 through 2011 and how these rates compared with other federal agencies; (2) attrition in DHS senior leadership positions, how attrition compares with other federal agencies, and actions DHS has taken to identify causes of senior leadership attrition; and (3) programs to help address senior- leadership hiring and recruitment. GAO calculated vacancy and attrition rates using Office of Personnel Management (OPM) data. GAO also used National Finance Center (NFC) payroll data obtained from DHS in vacancy rate calculations. There is no generally agreed upon standard for vacancy rates. However, to provide perspective, using OPM data, GAO calculated vacancy rates for other agencies subject to the Chief Financial Officers (CFO) Act of 1990 and compared them with DHS. GAO found the OPM and NFC data sufficiently reliable to calculate vacancy and attrition rates. To determine actions taken to identify attrition causes and efforts to enhance recruitment and retention, GAO reviewed agency documents, interviewed DHS human capital officials, and considered human capital practices GAO has previously recommended. What GAO Found: The Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) senior leadership vacancy rates, while reaching a peak of 25 percent in 2006, have generally declined since that time—from 25 percent in fiscal year 2006 to 10 percent at the end of fiscal year 2011. From fiscal years 2006 through 2010—the most recent year for which governmentwide vacancy and attrition data were available—DHS vacancy rates in 2006, 2007, and 2010 were statistically higher than the average of other agencies subject to the Chief Financial Officers (CFO) Act but were not statistically different in 2008 and 2009. DHS’s components’—such as the Transportation Security Administration and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement—vacancy rates varied. Many had vacancy rates above 20 percent-—one as high as 57 percent-—in fiscal year 2006, but generally had lower rates at the end of fiscal year 2011. At the end of fiscal year 2010, DHS’s senior leadership attrition rate was 11.4 percent. For fiscal years 2006 through 2010, the most frequent separation types were retirements and resignations. DHS’s attrition rates were statistically higher than the average of other CFO agencies in 2006, 2007, and 2009 but not statistically different in 2008 and 2010. In January 2010, DHS deployed an exit survey to be sent to all separating employees. DHS analyzed survey responses from 17 self-identified senior executives. The top three survey choices selected regarding reasons for leaving were 1) supervisor/management, 2) personal or family-related reasons, and 3) salary/pay. DHS officials implemented two programs to enhance senior leadership hiring and recruitment. In fiscal year 2010, DHS implemented a simplified pilot hiring process aiming to attract additional qualified applicants. According to DHS officials, the pilot was successful, and they now plan to use the method for all Senior Executive Service hiring. DHS also implemented a centralized candidate-development program aimed at providing a consistent approach to leadership training. GAO provided a draft of this report to DHS. DHS reiterated the actions it is taking to enhance senior leadership recruitment and hiring. Figure: DHS Senior Executive Service Vacancies Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: line graph] Fiscal year: 2006; Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 25%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 22%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Fiscal year: 2007; Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 22%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Fiscal year: 2008; Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Fiscal year: 2009; Vacancy rate per pay period: 7%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 8%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 8%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Fiscal year: 2010; Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Fiscal year: 2011; Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Fiscal year: 2012; Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] View [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-12-264]. For more information, contact David C. Maurer at (202) 512-9627 or maurerd@gao.gov. [End of section] Contents: Letter: Background: DHS SES Vacancy Rates Have Generally Declined, Have Been Higher Than Other Federal Agencies at Times, and Have Varied for Specific DHS Components: Resignations and Retirements Were the Most Common Reasons for Separation; Attrition Rates Were Higher: Than Other CFO Agencies in Some Years: Agency Comments and Our Evaluation: Appendix I: Department of Homeland Security's Components Senior Executive Service Vacancy Rates from 2006 to 2011: Appendix II: Department of Homeland Security's Components Senior Leadership Attrition from 2006 to 2010: Appendix III: Comments from the Department of Homeland Security: Appendix IV: GAO Contact and Staff Acknowledgments: Tables: Table 1: Senior Leadership Position Allocations, as of Sept. 30, 2011: Table 2: DHS and Other CFO Act Agencies' SES Vacancy Rates, as of September 30, 2010 (in percentages): Table 3: DHS Component SES On-Board Numbers and Vacancy Rates, as of the Beginning and End of Fiscal Year 2011: Table 4: Number and Type of Separations for Senior Leadership Positions DHS-Wide, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2010: Table 5: DHS Attrition Relative to Other CFO Act Agencies as of September 30, 2010 (in percentages): Table 6: Fiscal Year 2006 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Table 7: Fiscal Year 2007 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Table 8: Fiscal Year 2008 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Table 9: Fiscal Year 2009 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Table 10: Fiscal Year 2010 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Table 11: DHS Components' Attrition Rates by Fiscal Year: Figures: Figure 1: DHS SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 2: DHS and Average of Other CFO Act Agency SES Vacancy Rates for Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 3: USCIS SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 4: CPB SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 5: FEMA SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 6: ICE SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 7: TSA TSES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Figure 8: USSS SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: Abbreviations: CDP: Candidate Development Program: CFO: Chief Financial Officer: CBP: United States Customs & Border Protection: CPDF: Central Personnel Data File: DHS: Department of Homeland Security: ESCS: Executive and Schedule C System: ECQ: Executive Core Qualifications: FEMA: Federal Emergency Management Agency: NFC: National Finance Center: OCHCO: Office of the Chief Human Capital Officer: OMB: Office of Management and Budget: OPM: Office of Personnel Management: SES: Senior Executive Service: SL: Senior Level: ST: Scientific/Professional: TSA: Transportation Security Administration: TSES: Transportation Security Executive Service: USCG: United States Coast Guard: USCIS: United States Citizenship & Immigration Services: USSS: United States Secret Service: [End of section] United States Government Accountability Office: Washington, DC 20548: February 10, 2012: The Honorable Joseph I. Lieberman: Chairman: The Honorable Susan M. Collins: Ranking Member: Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs: United States Senate: The Honorable Daniel K. Akaka: Chairman: Subcommittee on Government Management Oversight, the Federal Workforce, and the District of Columbia: Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs: United State Senate: Since its creation, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has faced scrutiny from Congress and others concerning DHS's ability to hire and retain senior executives. July 2007 and June 2008 reports from the majority staff of the House Committee on Homeland Security and the National Academy of Public Administration, respectively, each raised concerns about the number of vacant senior leadership positions at DHS.[Footnote 1] DHS has acknowledged, in its human capital strategic plan, facing challenges in recruiting and hiring qualified individuals to fill vacancies at the senior executive level. As we reported in June 2007, high-performing organizations understand that they need senior leaders who are accountable for results, drive continuous improvement, and stimulate and support efforts to integrate human capital approaches with organizational goals and related transformation.[Footnote 2] Moreover, as we reported in April 2008, extensive loss of experienced workers can lead to critical gaps in an agency's leadership, skills, and institutional knowledge.[Footnote 3] In 2003, we designated implementing and transforming DHS as high risk because DHS had to transform 22 agencies--several with major management challenges--into one department, and failure to effectively address DHS's management and mission risks could have serious consequences for U.S. national and economic security. Human capital was among the challenges for implementing and transforming DHS that we identified.[Footnote 4] In our most recent update of the high risk work, we noted that in December 2010, DHS issued its Workforce Strategy for Fiscal Years 2011-2016, which contains the department's workforce goals, objectives, and performance measures for human capital management. We identified implementing this strategy and linking workforce-planning efforts to strategic and program-specific planning efforts to identify current and future human-capital needs as one of the key outcomes that are critical to addressing DHS's implementation and transformation challenges.[Footnote 5] DHS relies on four types of senior leadership positions to operate and oversee nearly every activity in the department: (1) Presidential appointments (with or without Senate confirmation); (2) Senior Executive Service (SES) personnel who carry out managerial, supervisory, and policy advisory responsibilities;[Footnote 6] (3) Senior Level (SL) personnel who provide expertise in complex areas that generally do not have a managerial focus, and (4) Scientific/ Professional (ST) personnel who are specialized professionals who generally have fundamental research and development responsibilities. The senior leadership vacancies and attrition examined in this report do not include Presidential appointments (with or without Senate confirmation). Given the importance of senior leadership and DHS's mission to prevent terrorism, secure our borders and cyberspace, and ensure resilience to disasters, you requested that we review senior leadership vacancies at DHS, including efforts to identify their causes and address them. [Footnote 7] This report addresses the following questions: 1. What were vacancy rates in DHS senior leadership positions from fiscal years 2006 through 2011, and how do these vacancy rates compare with other federal agencies? 2. What were the attrition rates in DHS senior leadership positions from fiscal years 2006 through 2010, how do these rates compare with other federal agencies, and what actions has DHS taken to identify causes of senior leadership attrition? 3. What programs has DHS implemented to enhance senior leadership hiring and recruitment? DHS officials reported that a number of different factors or events have influenced the department's vacancy rates at various points in time and for variable durations--including OPM's authorization of additional senior level allocations, department and component reorganizations, and political transitions. When vacancy rates fluctuate, single data points may not provide a representative picture of vacancy conditions. Therefore, we calculated trends based on vacancy rates derived at multiple points in time from fiscal years 2006 through 2011. We analyzed DHS senior leadership vacancy and attrition information for the entire DHS organization. We also separately analyzed information for the following DHS components: United States Customs & Border Protection (CBP), United States Citizenship & Immigration Services (USCIS), United States Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE), Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), United States Secret Service (USSS), and the United States Coast Guard (USCG). We did not separately analyze vacancy information for USCG because of the relatively low number of USCG senior leadership positions. Our analysis of vacancy rates at DHS and its components focused on SES--including Transportation Security Executive Service (TSES)-- positions because DHS components had few SL and ST positions during the review period.[Footnote 8] To determine SES vacancy rates from fiscal years 2006 through 2011, we analyzed departmental and component information on senior level allocations and on-board data by pay period. We used information on allocations contained in the letters sent from the Office of Personnel Management (OPM) to DHS's Office of the Chief Human Capital Officer (OCHCO) informing DHS of the number of positions allocated.[Footnote 9] DHS's Human Capital Business Systems Office provided on-board data by pay period, using the National Finance Center (NFC) payroll and personnel database that has been adopted by multiple government agencies.[Footnote 10] We calculated vacancy rates for each pay period by subtracting the number of staff on board from the current allocation to obtain a vacancy count and dividing that vacancy count by the allocation. To determine how DHS's SES vacancy rates compare with other federal agencies, we obtained the number of on-board and allocated SES positions for agencies across the federal government subject to the Chief Financial Officers (CFO) Act of 1990 from OPM's Central Personnel Data File (CPDF) and Executive and Schedule C System (ESCS), respectively.[Footnote 11] We calculated the respective end of fiscal year vacancy rates for DHS and for other CFO Act agencies and applied a t-test--a standard statistical test to determine whether the differences in this type of data are significant--to determine whether there is a statistical difference between DHS and other CFO Act agency vacancy rates. Our analysis of senior leadership attrition at DHS includes positions in the SES (including TSES), ST, and SL categories. To determine attrition rates at DHS and other CFO agencies from fiscal years 2006 through 2010, we analyzed data from OPM's CDPF for information on separations by type, such as through resignation, transfers, retirement, termination, and expiration of a term appointment. We calculated the average number of executives on board by averaging (1) the number of senior executive staff in the CPDF as of the last pay period of the fiscal year prior to the fiscal year for which the attrition rate was calculated and (2) the number of senior executive staff in CPDF as of the last pay period of the fiscal year in which the attrition occurred. We calculated attrition rates by dividing the number of separations in a fiscal year by the average number of executives on board. To determine the actions DHS has taken to identify the causes of senior level attrition and the efforts DHS has undertaken to enhance senior leadership recruitment and retention, we reviewed relevant agency documents, such as DHS's Strategic Human Capital Plan and DHS's Workforce Strategy for fiscal years 2011-2016. We also interviewed officials in DHS's OCHCO and human capital officials in select DHS components. We considered the initiatives DHS has undertaken and which, if any, of our previous human capital recommendations might apply to DHS's senior leadership efforts. 1To assess the reliability of the NFC database for providing on-board data for senior leadership positions, we reviewed relevant documentation and conducted interviews with knowledgeable DHS human capital agency officials to understand how DHS collects, categorizes, and tabulates the data and the actions it takes to ensure its consistency, accuracy, and completeness. We determined the NFC on- board data provided by DHS to be sufficiently reliable for presenting the number of executives on board and calculating vacancy rates by pay period for fiscal years 2006 through 2011.To determine the reliability of data obtained from OPM's CPDF, we reviewed the data system's technical documentation, as well as our prior work in which we reported that governmentwide data from the CPDF were 97 percent or more accurate.[Footnote 12] We determined that the CPDF data we use in this report are sufficiently reliable for presenting the number of executives on board as well as the number of separations at DHS, its components, and other CFO Act agencies, and for calculating vacancy and attrition rates. To determine the reliability of data obtained from OPM's ESCS, we reviewed the data system's technical documentation and conducted interviews with knowledgeable OPM officials to understand the actions OPM takes to ensure the data's consistency, accuracy, and completeness. We determined that the ESCS data we use in this report are sufficiently reliable for the purposes of calculating vacancy rates. We conducted this performance audit from October 2010 through January 2012 in accordance with generally accepted government auditing standards. Those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain sufficient, appropriate evidence to provide a reasonable basis for our findings and conclusions based on our audit objectives. We believe the evidence provides a reasonable basis for our findings and conclusions based on our audit objectives. Background: DHS Workforce: With more than 200,000 employees doing diverse jobs--for example, aviation and border security, emergency response, cybersecurity analysis, and chemical facility inspection--DHS is the third largest cabinet-level agency in the federal government. The DHS workforce is situated throughout the nation carrying out activities to support DHS's multipronged mission to: (1) prevent terrorism and enhance security; (2) secure and manage the nation's borders; (3) enforce and administer immigration laws; (5) safeguard and secure cyberspace; and (6) ensure resilience from disasters. As of September 30, 2011, DHS had 624 SES and 164 TSES allocations, 36 ST allocations, and 29 SL allocations for a total of 853 senior leadership positions. Table 1 shows how DHS allocated these senior leadership positions among the components and headquarters offices, as of September 30, 2011. Table 1: Senior Leadership Position Allocations, as of Sept. 30, 2011: Components: CBP; Total Positions Allocated: 118. Components: FEMA; Total Positions Allocated: 81. Components: ICE; Total Positions Allocated: 82. Components: TSA; Total Positions Allocated: 164. Components: USCIS; Total Positions Allocated: 58. Components: USCG; Total Positions Allocated: 20. Components: USSS; Total Positions Allocated: 53. Components: DHS Headquarters and Other Offices[A]; Total Positions Allocated: 278. Components: Total; Total Positions Allocated: 854. Source: DHS OCHCO. [A] DHS headquarters includes the following: Office of the Secretary, Deputy Secretary, and Immediate Offices; Office of the General Counsel; Office of the Under Secretary for Intelligence and Analysis; Office of the Assistant Secretary for Policy; Office of the Operations Coordination and Planning Directorate; Office of Health Affairs/Chief Medical Officer; Office of the Under Secretary for Management; Office of the Under Secretary for Science and Technology; Office of the Under Secretary for National Protection and Programs Directorate; Domestic Nuclear Detection Office; and the Federal Law Enforcement Training Center. [End of table] How Vacancies in Senior Leadership Positions Come to Exist: Vacancies are created primarily in two circumstances. First, vacancies are created when employees separate from the organization, leaving a position unfilled. Second, vacancies are created when positions are created but not yet filled--such as when agencies receive additional allocations of senior leadership positions for which an employee has yet to be hired. Separations: Separations are actions that end employment with an agency. Separations include expiration of limited term appointments, retirements, resignations, terminations, transfers, removals, separations due to reduction in force, separations to enter the uniformed services, and deaths.[Footnote 13] Allocations: OPM, in consultation with the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), allocates senior leadership positions every 2 years. [Footnote 14] In consultation with OMB, OPM reviews requests from each department and agency and authorizes a specific number of SES positions for the 2 fiscal years covered by the requests. Within the allocation authorized by OMB, DHS may establish SES positions in accordance with OPM guidance as well as applicable law and regulation without further OPM approval. DHS allocates these positions among its components and its headquarters offices. In addition, OPM allows out- of-cycle requests for additional allocations if a pressing, unforeseen need arises. When DHS receives new allocations from OPM those positions appear as vacancies until they are filled. DHS SES Vacancy Rates Have Generally Declined, Have Been Higher Than Other Federal Agencies at Times, and Have Varied for Specific DHS Components: DHS SES Vacancy Rates Declined through Fiscal Year 2009, Rose in 2010 as a Result of Organizational Factors, and Declined Again in 2011: DHS SES vacancy rates have been as high as 25 percent in 2006 and since that time have varied but have generally declined. As of the end of fiscal year 2011, DHS's SES (including TSES) vacancy rate was 10 percent.[Footnote 15] Increases in vacancy rates tended to be pronounced at times immediately following the receipt of new allocations. For example, following OPM's allocation of 90 new SES positions in October 2009, the vacancy rate rose from 11.3 percent to 20.8 percent as additional positions to be filled were granted. Following that rise in the vacancy rate it remained elevated through the remainder of fiscal 2010--between 17.1 percent and 20.2 percent. DHS officials attributed the elevation during 2010 to a series of organizational factors including, departmental position reevaluations, delays in assigning allocations among the components, and changes in recruitment and hiring processes. For example, according to DHS OCHCO officials, the 90 new SES positions DHS received in fiscal year 2010 were less than half those originally requested by a prior administration and need to be reevaluated to determine whether they were directed toward programs most critical to the new administration. Figure 1: DHS SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: line graph] Fiscal year: 2006; Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 25%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 24%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 22%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 23%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Fiscal year: 2007; Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 573. Vacancy rate per pay period: 22%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Fiscal year: 2008; Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 646. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 686. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 700. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Fiscal year: 2009; Vacancy rate per pay period: 7%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 8%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 8%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Fiscal year: 2010; Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 11%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 710. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 21%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 20%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 19%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Fiscal year: 2011; Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 18%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 17%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 16%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 15%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 14%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 13%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 12%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Vacancy rate per pay period: 9%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Fiscal year: 2012; Vacancy rate per pay period: 10%; Allocations of SES positions to DHS: 788. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] DHS Vacancy Rates Were, at Times, Statistically Higher Than Other CFO Act Agencies: Although there is no generally agreed-upon standard for acceptable vacancy rates, to provide perspective, we compared DHS's rates to other CFO Act agencies. From fiscal years 2006 through 2010--the most recent year for which federalwide vacancy-rate data were available-- DHS vacancy rates were at times statistically higher than other CFO Act agencies. Figure 2 shows the CFO vacancy rate at the end of each fiscal year in our review period, relative to the DHS vacancy rate at the same point in time and the highest and lowest DHS vacancy rates during each fiscal year. For example, in fiscal year 2010, the DHS vacancy rate at the end of the year was 17 percent and ranged from a low of 8.4 percent to a high of 20.7 percent during the course of the year. This compares to an average vacancy rate across other CFO agencies of 9.0 percent at the end of fiscal year 2010. Figure 2: DHS and Average of Other CFO Act Agency SES Vacancy Rates for Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: multiple line graph] Fiscal year: 2006; DHS Low: 21.1%; DHS (CPDF): 19.9%; DHS High: 25%; CFO (CPDF): 12.9%. Fiscal year: 2007; DHS Low: 12%; DHS (CPDF): 14.9%; DHS High: 22.5%; CFO (CPDF): 11.3%. Fiscal year: 2008; DHS Low: 7%; DHS (CPDF): 10.8%; DHS High: 18.4%; CFO (CPDF): 10.7%. Fiscal year: 2009; DHS Low: 8.5%; DHS (CPDF): 8.7%; DHS High: 14.2%; CFO (CPDF): 9.3%. Fiscal year: 2010; DHS Low: 11.1%; DHS (CPDF): 17%; DHS High: 20.8%; CFO (CPDF): 9%. Fiscal year: 2011; DHS Low: 9.4%; DHS (CPDF): 9.6%; DHS High: 18.3%; CFO (CPDF): No Data. Source: CPDF and NPC data; GAO analysis. Note: Department of Justice's practices when reporting on-board data to OPM or inclusion in the CPDF did not allow for us to accurately calculate its vacancy rate. From fiscal years 2006 through 2010, Department of Justice vacancy rates calculated using CPDF data resulted in negative vacancy rates (ranging from -34.1 percent to - 54.1 percent). Department of Justice officials explained that the United States Attorney General was provided separate authority to establish a personnel system for senior personnel within the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Drug Enforcement Administration. See 5 U.S.C. § 3151. On-board data for these Justice components were included in the data reported to OPM, resulting in an on-board number that was not proportionate to the OPM allocation data we used in our calculation. Therefore, we excluded the department from the CFO Act agency comparisons. [End of figure] We performed tests of statistical significance, which demonstrated whether there was a statistical difference in vacancy rates between DHS and the average for other CFO Act agencies and determined that the DHS vacancy rate was statistically higher than the CFO average rate in fiscal years 2006, 2007, and 2010. DHS's rate was not statistically different than the average of other CFO Act agencies in fiscal years 2008 and 2009. Table 2 shows DHS's vacancy rates relative to other CFO Act agencies, including the direction of statistical difference, for each of these fiscal years. Of note is that the number of newly allocated SES positions at DHS, particularly in 2007 and 2010, relative to most other CFO Act agencies is substantially higher. We could not compare DHS's vacancy rate at the end of fiscal year 2011 with other CFO Act agencies because comparable data from these agencies were not yet available. Table 2: DHS and Other CFO Act Agencies' SES Vacancy Rates, as of September 30, 2010 (in percentages): Department of Agriculture: Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 10.4%; Total Allocated: 402; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 9.0%; Total Allocated: 402; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 15.4%; Total Allocated: 408; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 13.0%; Total Allocated: 399; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 8.8%; Total Allocated: 399. Department of Commerce: Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 6.9%; Total Allocated: 378; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 4.5%; Total Allocated: 378; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 1.3%; Total Allocated: 378; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 0.0%[A]; Total Allocated: 370; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 0.3%; Total Allocated: 373. Department of Defense; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 10.9%; Total Allocated: 1,378; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 8.8%; Total Allocated: 1,378; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 8.8%; Total Allocated: 1,401; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 9.2%; Total Allocated: 1,397; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 5.6%; Total Allocated: 1,423. Department of Education; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 2.2%; Total Allocated: 90; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 5.6%; Total Allocated: 90; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 0.0%; Total Allocated: 90; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 4.8%; Total Allocated: 83; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 8.1%; Total Allocated: 86. Department of Energy; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 3.2%; Total Allocated: 471; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 1.5%; Total Allocated: 471; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 0.0%[A]; Total Allocated: 471; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 0.4%; Total Allocated: 470; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 5.4%; Total Allocated: 480. Department of Health and Human Services; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 25.0%; Total Allocated: 529; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 22.1%; Total Allocated: 529; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 19.1%; Total Allocated: 529; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 19.6%; Total Allocated: 2009: 514; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 12.1%; Total Allocated: 514. Department of Homeland Security; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 19.9%; Total Allocated: 573; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 14.9%; Total Allocated: 646; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 10.8%; Total Allocated: 710; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 8.7%; Total Allocated: 698; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 17.0%; Total Allocated: 788. Department of Housing and Urban Development; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 13.8%; Total Allocated: 116; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 10.3%; Total Allocated: 116; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 7.8%; Total Allocated: 116; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 6.6%; Total Allocated: 106; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 0.0%[A]; Total Allocated: 111. Department of the Interior; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 6.1%; Total Allocated: 280; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 8.9%; Total Allocated: 280; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 6.8%; Total Allocated: 280; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 1.9%; Total Allocated: 270; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 2.2%; Total Allocated: 273. Department of Labor; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 28.5%; Total Allocated: 193; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 21.8%; Total Allocated: 193; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 18.1%; Total Allocated: 199; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 14.7%; Total Allocated: 191; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 22.9%; Total Allocated: 201. Department of State; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 17.7%; Total Allocated: 192; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 18.8%; Total Allocated: 192; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 15.9%; Total Allocated: 195; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 22.5%; Total Allocated: 191; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 12.4%; Total Allocated: 194. Department of Transportation; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 17.5%; Total Allocated: 251; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 12.4%; Total Allocated: 251; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 12.7%; Total Allocated: 251; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 11.8%; Total Allocated: 238; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 11.9%; Total Allocated: 244. Department of the Treasury; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 9.7%; Total Allocated: 454; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 8.1%; Total Allocated: 454; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 9.1%; Total Allocated: 484; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 1.5%; Total Allocated: 473; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 7.2%; Total Allocated: 502. Department of Veterans Affairs; Fiscal Year: 2006: Rate: 25.6%; Total Allocated: 320; Fiscal Year: 2007: Rate: 24.4%; Total Allocated: 320; Fiscal Year: 2008: Rate: 27.9%; Total Allocated: 337; Fiscal Year: 2009: Rate: 24.5%; Total Allocated: 335; Fiscal Year: 2010: Rate: 30.8%; Total Allocated: 406. Environmental Protection Agency; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 7.9%; Total Allocated: 305; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 7.2%; Total Allocated: 305; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 9.4%; Total Allocated: 309; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 12.3%; Total Allocated: 300; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 7.9%; Total Allocated: 303. Fiscal Year: General Services Administration; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 21.9%; Total Allocated: 114; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 14.9%; Total Allocated: 114; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 16.2%; Total Allocated: 117; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 17.1%; Total Allocated: 111; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 11.7%; Total Allocated: 111. Fiscal Year: National Aeronautics and Space Administration; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 11.0%; Total Allocated: 480; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 8.1%; Total Allocated: 480; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 5.4%; Total Allocated: 480; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 6.9%; Total Allocated: 475; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 7.4%; Total Allocated: 475. Fiscal Year: National Science Foundation; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 19.6%; Total Allocated: 107; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 16.8%; Total Allocated: 107; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 19.6%; Total Allocated: 107; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 13.6%; Total Allocated: 103; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 17.5%; Total Allocated: 103. Fiscal Year: Nuclear Regulatory Commission; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 6.2%; Total Allocated: 162; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 12.6%; Total Allocated: 167; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 11.6%; Total Allocated: 172; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 4.1%; Total Allocated: 169; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 5.3%; Total Allocated: 170. Fiscal Year: Office of Personnel Management; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 17.7%; Total Allocated: 62; [Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 17.7%; Total Allocated: 62; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 15.6%; Total Allocated: 64; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 5.2%; Total Allocated: 58; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 13.4%; Total Allocated: 67. Fiscal Year: Small Business Administration; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 22.0%; Total Allocated: 59; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 16.9%; Total Allocated: 59; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 11.9%; Total Allocated: 59; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 0.0%[A]; Total Allocated: 54; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 1.9%; Total Allocated: 54. Fiscal Year: Social Security Administration; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 3.7%; Total Allocated: 161; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 10.6%; Total Allocated:161; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 13.8%; Total Allocated: 174; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 9.1%; Total Allocated: 164; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 8.3%; Total Allocated: 169. Fiscal Year: US Agency for International Development; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 55.0%; Total Allocated: 40; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 45.0%; Total Allocated: 40; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 42.5%; Total Allocated: 40; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 6.3%; Total Allocated: 32; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 3.1%; Total Allocated: 32. Fiscal Year: CFO average/total (excluding DHS and Justice)[B]; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: 12.9%; Total Allocated: 6,544; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: 11.3%; Total Allocated: 6,549; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: 10.7%; Total Allocated: 6,661; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: 9.3%; Total Allocated: 6,503; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: 9.0%; Total Allocated: 6,690. Fiscal Year: DHS Significance Direction; Fiscal Year: 2006; Rate: Higher; Fiscal Year: 2007; Rate: Higher; Fiscal Year: 2008; Rate: Not Significant; Fiscal Year: 2009; Rate: Not Significant; Fiscal Year: 2010; Rate: Higher. Source: GAO Analysis of CPDF data. [A] OPM may authorize an agency, in certain circumstances and upon request, a temporary SES position that would increase the number of SES at an agency beyond its allocation. In these circumstances, an agency's vacancy rate would be calculated as a negative number, but they are set to 0 for this table, to acknowledge that such overages are not permanent. [B] Department of Justice's practices when reporting on-board data to OPM or inclusion in the CPDF did not allow for us to accurately calculate its vacancy rate. From fiscal years 2006 through 2010, Department of Justice vacancy rates calculated using CPDF data resulted in negative vacancy rates (ranging from -34.1 percent to - 54.1 percent). Department of Justice officials explained that the United States Attorney General was provided separate authority to establish a personnel system for senior personnel within the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Drug Enforcement Administration. See 5 U.S.C. § 3151. On-board data for these Justice components were included in the data reported to OPM, resulting in an on-board number that was not proportionate to the OPM allocation data we used in our calculation. Therefore, we excluded the department from the CFO Act agency comparisons. [End of table] DHS Components' Vacancy Rates Varied Widely from Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011, but Have Largely Declined Since 2006: Vacancy rates for DHS components varied widely during fiscal years 2006 through 2011. Component officials reported a number of different factors that may have contributed to component SES vacancy rates during that time period, including increases in allocations, events like Presidential transitions, and organizational factors such as reorganizations. Overall, component vacancy rates declined between 2006 and 2011. USCIS, CBP, ICE, and FEMA all had lower vacancy rates in September 2011 than they had in the first pay period of 2006. Only TSA's rate was higher in 2011 than 2006. USSS's 2006 and 2011 rates were similar, and USSS's rate never exceeded 20 percent. Table 3 shows component vacancy rates and on-board counts at the beginning and end of fiscal year 2011. For more information about component vacancy rates, see appendix I. With the exception of TSA, all components experienced declining vacancy rates in 2011 and except FEMA all had rates lower than 20 percent at the end of fiscal year 2011. Table 3: DHS Component SES On-Board Numbers and Vacancy Rates, as of the Beginning and End of Fiscal Year 2011: Component: CBP; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 98; Fiscal year 2011 End: 106; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 15.5%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 8.%. Component: FEMA; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 66; Fiscal year 2011 End: 64; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 17.5%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 20.0%. Component: ICE; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 55; Fiscal year 2011 End: 71; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 32.9%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 13.4%. Component: TSA; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 138; Fiscal year 2011 End: 132; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 15.9%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 19.5%. Component: USCIS; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 44; Fiscal year 2011 End: 51; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 24.1%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 12.1%. Component: USCG; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 16; Fiscal year 2011 End: 19; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 20.0%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 5.0%. Component: USSS; 2011 total on board: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 50; Fiscal year 2011 End: 51; 2011 vacancy rates: Fiscal year 2011 Start: 2.0%; Fiscal year 2011 End: 0.0%. Source: GAO Analysis of NFC and OPM Data. [End of table] Several components--CBP, FEMA, ICE, and USCIS--had vacancy rates near or higher than 20 percent in fiscal year 2006; however, most components experienced a decline in vacancy rates between fiscal year 2006 and the early part of fiscal 2007. Officials from USCIS, for example, reported that in calendar years 2006 and 2007, USCIS filled 27 positions while experiencing only 4 new vacancies. As a result, USCIS experienced a significant drop in its vacancy rates--from 56.7 percent in pay period 1 (January) of 2006 to 3.3 percent in pay period 8 (April) of 2007. In May 2007, corresponding with new allocations, most components' rates rose again. For example, USCIS's SES allocations increased from 32 to 46 in May 2007. Correspondingly, from pay period 8 to pay period 9 in 2007 (April/May), USCIS's vacancy rate rose from 3.3 percent to 37 percent. Similarly, CBP's vacancy rate rose from 2.4 to 21.2; ICE's rose from 12.8 to 32.8, and FEMA's rose from 9.8 to 27.4 due, at least in part, to increased allocations for SES positions. Following the additional allocations in fiscal year 2007, CBP, ICE, and USCIS vacancy rates followed a similar pattern, generally declining as the newly created positions were filled then remaining relatively steady until receiving another sizable increase in allocations in July 2010. For example, USCIS received 8 new allocations in July 2010, increasing its authorized SES level from 50 to 58. As a result, USCIS's vacancy rate rose from 0 to 17.2 percent during this time. USSS, FEMA, and TSA rates did not necessarily follow this pattern of increasing rates corresponding with new allocations followed by declining rates for various reasons. First, FEMA vacancy rates experienced an increase in early to mid fiscal year 2009 that did not correspond to new allocations. According to FEMA officials, the 2009 spike in vacancies was because of resignations associated with a changing administration. The officials noted that this increase in vacancies continued through 2009. USSS had the lowest vacancy rates of all components considered, as well as the lowest number of total SES allocations (other than USCG, which we did not separately evaluate). Throughout the entire period, the USSS SES vacancy rates tended to be in the single digits, and separations were generally because of retirements, with only one resignation. Because USSS has relatively small numbers of SES--as of September 30, 2011, it had 51--small changes in filled positions can result in disproportionately large changes in vacancy rates. USSS's highest vacancy rates occurred from May through July 2010, when the rate increased from 10.4 percent to 19.6 percent. By July the end of 2010, USSS had filled these vacancies, and the rate had declined to 2 percent. Finally, TSA's TSES vacancy rates were generally more stable than some of the other components, in part, because it had fewer allocations during our study period. TSES positions are not included in the OPM SES allocation that DHS allots to the other components and therefore did not occur on the same schedule. TSA received one allocation of 14 additional TSES positions during our review period, in early to mid fiscal year 2008. This increase in allocations coincided with an increase in vacancy rates from 7.3 to 15.9 percent. However, unlike other components, TSA's vacancy rate did not subsequently decline. TSA's highest vacancy rates occurred the following year, coinciding with the change in administration, when the rate was as high as 23.2 percent. Overall, it remained near 20 percent from about April 2008 until the end of fiscal year 2011. Among the components, TSA's 164 TSES allocations are the highest number of senior leadership positions allocated. According to TSA's Director of Executive Resources, TSES vacancies do not necessarily reflect unfilled positions that TSA has funded and has an active need to fill. Because TSA does not have an SES allocation from OPM, TSA and DHS agreed on a TSES allocation, which functions as a ceiling rather than a specific number of positions that must be filled. She explained that TSA has continued to mature as an organization and has gone through a number of organization transformations. In the course of transformations, some TSES positions have been abolished and later reallocated. For example, according to the director, during its current transformation, TSA reduced 12 Office of Security Operations regions to 6 regions and reorganized 3 TSES per regional office to 1, thereby eliminating twelve SES positions. Those positions are then reflected as available in the TSES overall ceiling, but are not necessarily immediately reallocated for staffing. Additionally, she noted that in this tenth anniversary year, TSA has experienced a wave of retirements. In some cases, TSES officials transfer from their existing TSES positions to fill positions vacated by retirees. The director stated that TSA considers its highest organizational needs when it makes these TSES selections, whether through competition or transfers of current personnel. In October 2009, we reported on executive turnover at TSA. We found that TSA executive attrition declined from fiscal years 2005 through 2008, but better information was needed on reasons for leaving and the executive hiring process. We recommended that TSA enable TSES staff to identify their position when completing exit surveys and better document how it applies merit staffing requirements when hiring TSES staff. TSA concurred and, in March 2010, TSA updated the National Exit Survey instrument to include TSES among its preset list of position titles to allow for the collection of data specific to TSES staff taking the survey. In addition, in March 2010 TSA officials established a process to audit the TSES staffing files on a quarterly basis to ensure the completeness and accuracy of merit documentation. [Footnote 16] Resignations and Retirements Were the Most Common Reasons for Separation; Attrition Rates Were Higher Than Other CFO Agencies in Some Years: Retirements and Resignations Were the Leading Types of Senior Leadership Attrition in Fiscal Years 2006 through 2010: At the end of fiscal year 2010--the most recent period for which CPDF attrition data were available--DHS's attrition rate for all types of senior leadership (including SES, TSES, ST, and SL) separations was 11.4 percent.[Footnote 17] As table 4 shows, from fiscal years 2006 through 2010, the most frequent types of senior leadership separations were resignations--which were higher in the 2009 presidential transition year--and retirements, followed by transfers, and then by smaller numbers of terminations and other separations. Appendix II contains information about senior leadership attrition in the DHS components in fiscal years 2006 through 2010. Table 4: Number and Type of Separations for Senior Leadership Positions DHS-Wide, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2010: Type of separation: Fiscal Year. Type of separation: Resignations; Fiscal year: 2006: 45; Fiscal year: 2007: 23; Fiscal year: 2008: 28; Fiscal year: 2009[A]: 77; Fiscal year: 2010: 18; Total separations: 191. Type of separation: Retirements; Fiscal year: 2006: 42; Fiscal year: 2007: 42; Fiscal year: 2008: 37; Fiscal year: 2009[A]: 30; Fiscal year: 2010: 38; Total separations: 189. Type of separation: Transfers; Fiscal year: 2006: 17; Fiscal year: 2007: 15; Fiscal year: 2008: 14; Fiscal year: 2009[A]: 12; Fiscal year: 2010: 16; Total separations: 74. Type of separation: Terminations; Fiscal year: 2006: 2; Fiscal year: 2007: 3; Fiscal year: 2008: 1; Fiscal year: 2009[A]: 6; Fiscal year: 2010: 4; Total separations: 16. Type of separation: Other[B]; Fiscal year: 2006: 0; Fiscal year: 2007: 1; Fiscal year: 2008: 0; Fiscal year: 2009[A]: 5; Fiscal year: 2010: 3; Total separations: 19. Type of separation: Total separations; Fiscal year: 2006: 104; Fiscal year: 2007: 84; Fiscal year: 2008: 80; Fiscal year: 2009[A]: 130; Fiscal year: 2010: 79; Total separations: 479. Source: Data, CPDF; GAO Analysis. [A] 2009 was a presidential transition year. [B] Other includes infrequent types of attrition, such as the death of an employee. [End of table] DHS Attrition Was, at Times, Statistically Higher Than Other CFO Act Agencies: On the basis of CPDF data from September 30, 2010, DHS's attrition rate was 11.4 percent, compared with an average rate of 10.1 percent for other CFO Act agencies. As shown in table 5, according to our tests of statistical significance, this 2010 attrition rate was generally comparable to other CFO Act agencies and also generally comparable in 2008. However, the rate was statistically higher than other CFO Act agencies during fiscal years 2006, 2007, and 2009. Table 5: DHS Attrition Relative to Other CFO Act Agencies as of September 30, 2010 (in percentages): Department of Agriculture; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 9.0%; Average on board: 413; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.5%; Average on board: 424; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 16.8%; Average on board: 411.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 17.4%; Average on board: 401.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 7.5%; Average on board[A]:415. Department of Commerce; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 12.8%; Average on board: 407.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.8%; Average on board: 415; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 13.2%; Average on board: 423; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 13.6%; Average on board: 433.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 9.7%; Average on board[A]: 432. Department of Defense; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 13.7%; Average on board: 1367.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.7%; Average on board: 1395.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 11.3%; Average on board: 1428; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 14.6%; Average on board: 1435; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 9.6%; Average on board[A]: 1473.5. Department of Education; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 15.8%; Average on board: 88.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 16.0%; Average on board: 87.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 14.6%; Average on board: 89; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 27.4%; Average on board: 87.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 18.1%; Average on board[A]: 83. Department of Energy; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 12.5%; Average on board: 473.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 15.0%; Average on board: 481.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 11.9%; Average on board: 497.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 13.3%; Average on board: 505; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 11.5%; Average on board[A]: 496. Department of Health and Human Resources; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 9.2%; Average on board: 401; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 13.1%; Average on board: 419.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 12.0%; Average on board: 433; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 19.2%; Average on board: 432; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 8.8%; Average on board[A]: 442.5. Department of Homeland Security; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 22.1%; Average on board: 474.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 15.8%; Average on board: 533; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 12.7%; Average on board: 629; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 18.7%; Average on board: 680.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 11.4%; Average on board[A]: 690.5. Department of Housing and Urban Development; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 12.2%; Average on board: 98.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 10.7%; Average on board: 103; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 14.1%; Average on board: 106.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Fiscal year: 28.8%; Average on board: 104; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 10.3%; Average on board[A]: 106.5. Department of the Interior; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 12.8%; Average on board: 337; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 13.9%; Average on board: 331; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 10.8%; Average on board: 332; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 16.7%; Average on board: 340.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 10.4%; Average on board[A]: 345.5. Department of Justice; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 9.3%; Average on board: 720; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 10.9%; Average on board: 760; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 10.3%; Average on board: 808.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 14.6%; Average on board: 836.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 11.9%; Average on board[A]: 854. Department of Labor; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 8.1%; Average on board: 160; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 8.2%; Average on board: 159; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 12.8%; Average on board: 172; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 21.3%; Average on board: 178.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 16.0%; Average on board[A]: 175.5. Department of State; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 13.9%; Average on board: 165; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 17.0%; Average on board: 159; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 8.0%; Average on board: 161.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 35.0%; Average on board: 157; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 10.0%; Average on board[A]: 160. Department of Transportation; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 10.0%; Average on board: 210.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 10.0%; Average on board: 219.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 18.2%; Average on board: 225; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 23.7%; Average on board: 219.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 11.0%; Average on board[A]: 218.5. Department of the Treasury; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 17.5%; Average on board: 435.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 14.6%; Average on board: 430.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 14.5%; Average on board: 447.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 14.3%; Average on board: 474; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 13.7%; Average on board[A]: 490. Department of Veterans Affairs; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 13.8%; Average on board: 246; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.7%; Average on board: 243.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 9.6%; Average on board: 250.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 14.0%; Average on board: 257; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 12.3%; Average on board[A]: 275.5. Environmental Protection Agency; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 5.7%; Average on board: 314.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 7.3%; Average on board: 316; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 8.2%; Average on board: 319; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 13.6%; Average on board: 309.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 7.2%; Average on board[A]: 307. General Services Administration; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 21.3%; Average on board: 94; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 20.3%; Average on board: 93.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 13.1%; Average on board: 99; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 23.7%; Average on board: 97; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 8.2%; Average on board[A]: 97. National Aeronautics and Space Administration; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 13.7%; Average on board: 526; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.2%; Average on board: 531.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 8.5%; Average on board: 555; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 7.8%; Average on board: 574.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 6.6%; Average on board[A]: 576.5. National Science Foundation; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 8.1%; Average on board: 86.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 9.1%; Average on board: 87.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 9.1%; Average on board: 87.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 4.6%; Average on board: 87.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 12.6%; Average on board[A]: 87. Nuclear Regulatory Commission; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 8.7%; Average on board: 149; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.1%; Average on board: 149; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 14.8%; Average on board: 149; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 4.5%; Average on board: 157; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 6.2%; Average on board[A]: 161.5. Office of Personnel Management; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 40.0%; Average on board: 57.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 20.8%; Average on board: 53; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 9.2%; Average on board: 54.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 12.4%; Average on board: 56.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 8.5%; Average on board[A]: 59. Small Business Administration; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 18.6%; Average on board: 48.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 10.5%; Average on board: 47.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 21.8%; Average on board: 50.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 26.2%; Average on board: 53.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 9.3%; Average on board[A]: 54. Social Security Administration; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 4.0%; Average on board: 149.5; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 14.7%; Average on board: 149.5; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 10.9%; Average on board: 147; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 13.4%; Average on board: 149.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 10.5%; Average on board[A]: 152. United States Agency for International Development; Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 20.0%; Average on board: 20; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 14.3%; Average on board: 21; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 12.8%; Average on board: 23.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 10.7%; Average on board: 28; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 6.2%; Average on board[A]: 32.5. CFO average/total (excluding DHS); Fiscal year: 2006: Rate: 12.2%; Average on board: 6,969.0; Fiscal year: 2007: Rate: 12.6%; Average on board: 7,077.0; Fiscal year: 2008: Rate: 11.8%; Average on board: 7,270.5; Fiscal year: 2009: Rate: 15.4%; Average on board: 7,374.5; Fiscal year: 2010: Rate: 10.1%; Average on board[A]: 7,494,0. DHS Significance Direction; Fiscal year: 2006: Higher; Fiscal year: 2007: Higher; Fiscal year: 2008: Not Significant; Fiscal year: 2009: Higher; Fiscal year: 2010: Not Significant. Data Source: CPDF; GAO Analysis. [End of table] [A] We calculated average on-board figures by averaging (1) the number of senior executive staff in the CPDF as of the last pay period of the fiscal year prior to the fiscal year for which the attrition rate was calculated and (2) the number of senior executive staff in CPDF as of the last pay period of the fiscal year in which the attrition occurred. DHS Has Recently Implemented a New Exit Survey That Can Help Identify the Reasons DHS Senior Leaders Separate: DHS collects data on attrition and has taken preliminary steps to analyze the causes of senior leadership attrition. Our prior work on human capital and workforce planning, as well as the Standards for Internal Control in the Federal Government, indicate that identifying the causes of senior leadership attrition could support more effective human capital management. As part of a strategic workforce planning approach, we have reported that, in addition to attrition data, collecting information on why employees leave is useful. Specifically, we noted that collection and analysis of data on the reasons for attrition could help agencies minimize the lost investment in training, particularly when new employees resign.[Footnote 18] Similarly, according to Standards for Internal Control in the Federal Government, as part of human capital planning, management should consider, among other things, how best to retain valuable employees to ensure the continuity of needed skills and abilities.[Footnote 19] Consistent with the Standards for Internal Control and the practices we have advocated, DHS maintains and tracks attrition data for workforce monitoring and planning on agencywide and component-specific bases. The attrition data that DHS maintains include breakdowns by positions--such as SES, SL, and ST. In addition, in January 2010, DHS deployed its first departmentwide exit survey--the DHS National Exit Survey. When any employee voluntarily leaves DHS, they are to receive a link to the survey as part of exiting procedures. Results come directly to OCHCO and are analyzed on a quarterly basis. DHS has designed the survey to aid in its attrition data gathering and analysis. Separating employees, including senior leadership, are able to answer a series of questions about the reasons they decided to leave the department. Although DHS's survey responses are confidential, respondents are given an opportunity to, among other things, (1) identify their pay system (i.e., the position they held, such as SES, SL, or ST), (2) the component they are leaving, and (3) the office or area in which they work. According to the OCHCO officials, all components are using the DHS Exit Survey with the exception of TSA and USSS. They stated that both TSA and USSS already had a working exit survey in place, and so were given an exemption from using the DHS exit survey. Both components have incorporated the DHS core questions into their pre-existing exit surveys. According to senior human capital officials, it is their policy to refrain from analyzing survey results with fewer than 10 respondents in any category--such as the positions ST, SL, and SES--to protect the anonymity of survey respondents. Because DHS has not had the minimum number of senior leadership leaving in a given quarter, DHS has not been able to analyze the causes of senior leadership attrition on a quarterly basis. However, DHS has analyzed, in the aggregate, the senior leadership responses it has collected since it implemented the survey. That analysis demonstrated that 17 departing officials have self-identified as senior executives. The top three survey responses these senior executives selected as reasons for leaving were 1) supervisor/management, 2) personal or family-related reasons; and 3) salary/pay. In addition, some components--CBP, USCIS, and FEMA--reported that they separately use ad-hoc approaches to analyze attrition--including senior leadership attrition--for their workforces. For example, at FEMA, the top agency leadership officials conduct exit interviews with departing senior executives to discuss various matters, including reasons for separation. OCHCO officials said that their longer-term goal is to implement standardized out processing to improve their ability to collect and analyze information about senior leadership attrition, among other things, from these surveys. DHS Has Implemented Programs to Help Address Senior Leadership Hiring and Recruitment: We have previously reported key principles that strategic workforce planning should address, including developing strategies that address gaps and human capital conditions.[Footnote 20] DHS OCHCO officials identified two programs designed to enhance senior leadership hiring and recruitment: (1) a resume-only hiring process--which simplifies the process for applicants by streamlining application requirements and (2) a centralized SES candidate development program. Resume-Only Hiring Process. We reported in October 2009 that in a highly competitive job market, having an effective hiring process can help an agency compete for talented people who have the requisite knowledge and up-to-date skills to accomplish missions and achieve goals.[Footnote 21] In line with seeking to implement effective hiring processes, in 2010, DHS implemented a resume-only hiring process on a pilot basis to fill the 90 newly allocated SES positions across DHS received as part of the OPM's biennial review. The pilot resume-only process was used for internal and external applicants. The intent of the resume-only hiring process is to attract and generate a greater number of qualified applicants for executive-level positions than the traditional hiring method, which required narrative responses to five Executive Core Qualifications (ECQs).[Footnote 22] We reported in May 2008 that applicants can be dissuaded from public service by complex and lengthy application procedures.[Footnote 23] Under the resume-only method, the vacancy announcement directs applicants to submit only a resume, rather than answering essay questions and other application requirements. Applicants demonstrate ECQs and any technical qualifications within the context of the resume. Components also developed, in coordination with the Diversity, Recruitment, and Veterans Outreach team in OCHCO, outreach plans to develop marketing and advertising strategies that would appeal to affinity and diversity groups for the new senior leadership positions. DHS human capital officials reported that overall, the process has resulted in highly qualified pools of candidates from which they have made selections. According to the DHS Director, Executive Resources, the streamlined resume-only hiring process resulted in applicant pools doubling (in most instances) in comparison to applicant pools generated from the traditional method. As of December 2011, 84 of the 90 newly created senior leadership positions have been filled through the resume-only process.[Footnote 24] The DHS Director, Executive Resources reported that DHS now plans to use the resume only process as its primary method of filling SES positions. SES Candidate Development Program. We reported in June 2007 that among the tools human capital managers have at their disposal to help meet 21st century human capital needs are training and development programs.[Footnote 25] To build its senior leadership pipeline within the department, DHS offers future senior leadership from across the department, as well as external candidates, the opportunity to compete and be selected for DHS's SES Candidate Development Program (CDP), which DHS kicked off in May 2011. According to DHS officials, the CDP is designed to provide a unified, consistent approach to leadership training throughout the department. DHS has established performance metrics for the CDP program. These metrics include (1) OPM Qualification Review Board candidate- certification rates; (2) percent of SES CDP graduates who are placed in SES positions; (3) percent of DHS SES vacancies filled by CDP graduates; (4) diverse participants in the program; and (5) diverse selections for DHS SES positions.[Footnote 26] DHS does not yet have data on these metrics, because the first CDP cycle is not complete. According to DHS OCHCO officials, the latest date these participants would seek OPM certification would be August 1, 2013; however, they predict that most candidates will seek OPM certification around February or March 2013. The CDP process also provides DHS a framework with which to assess its future senior leadership workforce needs. To determine how many candidates should be selected for the CDP each year, the CDP policy requires DHS components to perform a needs assessment for senior leadership needs. The senior leadership workforce analysis consists of evaluating attrition rates over a 3-year period to determine (1) average annual attrition, (2) which executive vacancies have historically been filled internally and which externally, and (3) how many employees in the agency would be prepared to fill positions vacated by executives without further development. Each of the DHS components and offices completed the assessment for the first DHS SES CDP. Because this is the first year of the SES CDP, it is too soon to evaluate the effectiveness of the program or its workforce analysis process in helping to ensure adequate senior leadership at DHS. In addition to the CDP, the OPM administered Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey may provide DHS human capital managers with some information about senior leadership workforce needs. One purpose of the survey is to provide managers information about employee insight on leadership, performance culture, personal work experiences, and job satisfaction. According to DHS OCHCO, in the context of senior leaders, it considers survey questions about how likely employees are to leave or retire in the coming years as predictive but not wholly reliable indicators of upcoming workforce needs. We have an ongoing review of DHS morale, for the House Homeland Security Subcommittee on Oversight, Investigations and Management, that includes examining how DHS uses the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey to assess morale across the agency. We expect to report on our results later in 2012. Agency Comments and Our Evaluation: We provided a draft of this report for review to DHS. We received written comments on the draft report, which are reproduced in full in appendix IIII. DHS reiterated the actions it is taking to enhance senior leadership recruitment and hiring. DHS also provided technical comments, which we incorporated as appropriate. We are sending copies of this report to the Secretary of Homeland Security and interested congressional committees. The report is also available at no charge on GAO's website at [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov]. If you or your staff have any questions about this report please contact me at (202) 512-9627 or maurerd@gao.gov. Contact points for our Offices of Congressional Relations and Public Affairs may be found on the last page of this report. GAO staff who made major contributions to this report are listed in appendix IV. Signed by: David Maurer: Director, Homeland Security and Justice Issues: [End of section] Appendix I: Department of Homeland Security's Components Senior Executive Service Vacancy Rates from 2006 to 2011: This appendix illustrates vacancy rates from fiscal years 2006 through 2011[Footnote 27] in six of the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) components--U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the Transportation Security Administration (TSA), and the United States Secret Service (USSS). We did not separately analyze vacancy rates for the United States Coast Guard because the numbers of Senior Executive Service (SES) allocations were too low to meaningfully depict vacancy trends. The following series of figures depict vacancy rates on the top half of each figure and corresponding numbers of positions allocated and onboard counts on the bottom half. Vacancy rates change when employees fill or separate from an allocated positions and when components receive additional allocations. USCIS: As figure 3 shows, USCIS's SES vacancy rate was 56.7 percent in January 2006 and remained above 40 percent during the remainder of fiscal year 2006. In fiscal year 2007, USCIS received 16 additional allocations, increasing its vacancy rate above 30 percent for 9 consecutive pay periods (from April-September). The rate declined in the latter part of fiscal year 2008 to single-digit vacancy rates. USCIS received another allocation of 8 positions in fiscal year 2008, and the vacancy rate increased to 17.2 percent. The rate increased further with separations, reaching 24.1 percent (14 vacant positions) at the start of fiscal year 2011 and later peaking at 29.3 percent. By the end of fiscal year 2011, the rate declined to 12.1 percent (7 vacant positions). Figure 3: USCIS SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: 2 line graphs] Vacancy Rate: On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; 56.7%; 56.7%; 56.7%; 56.7%; 56.7%; 53.3%; 53.3%; 53.3%; 53.3%; 50%; 50%; 50%; 46.7%; 46.7%; 46.7%; 46.7%; 46.6%; 46.7%; 46.7%; 43.3%; 43.3%; 36.7%; 20%; 20%; 20%; 10%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; 10%; 6.7%; 6.7%; 6.1%; 6.7%; 6.7%; 6.7%; 3.3%; 37%; 37%; 37%; 37%; 37%; 37%; 37%; 34.8%; 32.6%; 26.1%; 30.4%; 21.7%; 21.7%; 21.7%; 21.7%; 21.7%; 21.7%; 19.6%; 17.4%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; 24%; 16%; 16%; 14%; 14%; 14%; 14%; 12%; 12%; 12%; 16.3%; 14%; 10%; 10%; 6%; 6%; 4%; 2%; 2%; 0%; 2%; 2%; 0%; 4%; 4%; 4%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; 4%; 9%; 8%; 8%; 8%; 6%; 6%; 8%; 8%; 8%; 8%; 8%; 8%; 8%; 10%; 6%; 6%; 6%; 6%; 4%; 2%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 4%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; 4%; 4%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 0%; 17.2%; 17.2%; 17.2%; 20.7%; 20.7%; 24.1%; 24.1%; 24.1%; 25.9%; 25.9%; 24.1%; 25.9%; 25.9%; 27.6%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; 29.3%; 27.6%; 27.6%; 27.6%; 27.6%; 24.1%; 22.4%; 22.4%; 20.7%; 17.2%; 19%; 19%; 22.4%; 19%; 19%; 15.5%; 15.5%; 12.1%; 12.1%; 12.1%. Allocation and on-board counts: Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 13. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 13. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 13. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 13. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 13. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 14. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 14. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 14. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 14. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 15. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 15. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 15. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 16. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 17. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 17. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 19. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 24. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 24. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 24. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 27. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 27. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 28. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 28. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 28. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 28. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 28. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 28. SEC Allocation: 30; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 30. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 31. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 34. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 32. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 37. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 38. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 35. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 46; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 50; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 42. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 58; On-board counts by pay period: 51. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] CBP: CBP had a single continuous period--from the time it received an allocation of 17 new positions in April 2007 through October 2007-- with a vacancy rate of 20 percent or more. Otherwise, CBP predominantly experienced vacancy rates in the teens or single digits during the review period. CBP started fiscal year 2011 at 15.5 percent (18 vacant positions) and closed the year at 8.6 percent (10 vacant positions). Figure 4: CPB SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: 2 line graphs] Vacancy Rate: On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; 19.5%; 20.7%; 18.3%; 18.3%; 17.1%; 19.5%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 15.9%; 18.3%; 15.9%; 15.9%; 15.9%; 15.9%; 13.4%; 12.2%; 14.6%; 13.4%; 12.2%; 12.2%; 8.5%; 4.9%; 3.7%; 3.7%; 3.7%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; 4.9%; 3.7%; 3.7%; 6.1%; 6.1%; 3.7%; 3.7%; 2.4%; 21.2%; 22.2%; 24.2%; 22.2%; 26.3%; 22.2%; 23.2%; 22.2%; 23.2%; 24.2%; 23.2%; 21.2%; 22.2%; 18.2%; 17.2%; 17.2%; 17.2%; 17.2%; 18.2%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; 20.6%; 19.6%; 18.6%; 18.6%; 18.6%; 18.6%; 18.6%; 16.7%; 16.7%; 15.7%; 13.7%; 11.8%; 10.8%; 9.8%; 9.8%; 9.8%; 3.9%; 2%; 1%; 1%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 1%; 0%; 2.9%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; 2.9%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2.9%; 2.9%; 2.9%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2.9%; 2.9%; 2%; 1%; 1%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 1%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; 1%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2.9%; 2.9%; 2.9%; 2.9%; 2%; 2%; 14.7%; 14.7%; 14.7%; 15.5%; 15.5%; 16.4%; 16.4%; 15.5%; 13.8%; 12.9%; 12.9%; 12.9%; 12.9%; 12.9%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; 12.1%; 12.1%; 11.2%; 10.3%; 9.5%; 10.3%; 10.3%; 9.5%; 8.6%; 6.9%; 7.8%; 6%; 6.9%; 9.4%; 8.6%; 5.2%; 6%; 6.9%; 7.8%; 8.6%. Allocation and on-board counts: Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 68. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 68. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 68. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 68. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 69. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 69. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 69. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 69. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 69. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 71. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 72. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 70. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 71. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 72. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 72. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 75. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 78. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 78. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 79. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 80. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 78. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 75. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 73. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 76. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 76. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 75. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 76. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 78. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 77. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 81. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 82. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 82. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 82. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 82. SEC Allocation: 99; On-board counts by pay period: 81. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 81. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 82. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 83. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 83. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 83. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 83. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 83. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 85. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 85. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 86. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 88. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 90. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 91. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 92. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 92. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 92. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 98. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 103. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 105. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 105. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 104. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 104. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 103. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 103. SEC Allocation: 102 On-board counts by pay period: 103. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 103. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 102; On-board counts by pay period: 99. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 98. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 98. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 97. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 97. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 98. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 100. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 101. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 102. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 103. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 104. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 105. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 104. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 104. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 105. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 106. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 108. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 107. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 109. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 108. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 105. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 106. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 110. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 109. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 108. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 107. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 106. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 106. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 106. SEC Allocation: 116; On-board counts by pay period: 106. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] FEMA: As figure 5 shows between 2006 and 2011, FEMA's SES vacancy rate varied. The vacancy rate was 35.3 percent in January 2006 and remained above 20 percent for the remainder of fiscal year 2006. The rate rose with allocations and then and declined in both fiscal year 2007 and fiscal year 2008. From early to mid fiscal year 2008 on FEMA's rate was near 20 percent. Near the middle of fiscal year 2009, separations increased the vacancy rate from 6.9 percent (5 vacant positions) to 29.2 percent (21 vacant positions) and remained near 30 percent for 16 pay periods. The rate decreased to 13.9 percent (10 vacant positions) by late fiscal year 2010, when it increased with a new allocation. At the start of fiscal year 2011, FEMA's SES vacancy rate was 17.5 percent (14 vacant positions), and by the end of the year was 20.0 percent (16 vacant positions). Figure 5: FEMA SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: 2 line graphs] Vacancy Rate: On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; 35.3%; 29.4%; 29.4%; 29.4%; 29.4%; 29.4%; 23.5%; 23.5%; 23.5%; 21.6%; 23.5%; 25.5%; 23.5%; 23.5%; 25.5%; 23.5%; 27.5%; 27.5%; 25.5%; 23.5%; 15.7%; 11.8%; 9.8%; 9.8%; 9.8%; 9.8%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; 9.8%; 11.8%; 11.8%; 13.7%; 13.7%; 11.8%; 9.8%; 9.8%; 27.4%; 27.4%; 27.4%; 29%; 25.8%; 25.8%; 25.8%; 22.6%; 21%; 21%; 22.6%; 22.6%; 12.9%; 12.9%; 12.9%; 11.3%; 11.3%; 9.7%; 9.7%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; 22.2%; 22.2%; 20.8%; 21.8%; 20.8%; 22.2%; 23.6%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 20.8%; 19.4%; 16.7%; 18.1%; 18.1%; 13.9%; 13.9%; 13.9%; 13.9%; 12.5%; 9.7%; 9.7%; 8.3%; 8.3%; 6.9%; 6.9%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; 6.9%; 29.2%; 29.2%; 29.2%; 31.9%; 30.6%; 30.6%; 30.6%; 31.9%; 31.9%; 30.6%; 30.6%; 29.2%; 30.6%; 29.2%; 29.2%; 29.2%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 23.6%; 20.8%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; 19.4%; 16.7%; 16.7%; 16.7%; 16.7%; 18.1%; 15.3%; 13.9%; 16.7%; 15.3%; 13.9%; 13.9%; 20.9%; 20%; 18.8%; 18.8%; 18.8%; 17.5%; 17.5%; 17.5%; 18.8%; 20%; 20%; 20%; 22.5%; 23.8%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; 23.8%; 25%; 25%; 25%; 23.8%; 23.8%; 21.3%; 20%; 20%; 22.5%; 20%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 22.5%; 22.5%; 22.5%; 20%. Allocation and on-board counts: Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006: SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 33. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 37. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 37. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 62; On-board counts by pay period: 56. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 58. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 59. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 59. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 67. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 57. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 58. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 59. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 72; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 66. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 61. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 80; On-board counts by pay period: 64. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] ICE: As figure 6 shows, ICE's SES vacancy rate was 38.3 percent in January 2006 and declined until ICE received a new allocation in the middle of fiscal year 2007, at which time the rate rose above 30 percent. The rate had decreased to 7.5 percent at the beginning of fiscal year 2010, when it increased to 25.4 percent as a result of separations. It rose again to 37.8 percent with a new allocation in late fiscal year 2010. At the start of fiscal year 2011 the vacancy rate was 32.9 percent (27 vacant positions). By the end of fiscal year 2011, the ICE SES vacancy rate had declined to 13.4 percent (11 vacant positions). Figure 6: ICE SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: 2 line graphs] Vacancy Rate: On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; 38.3%; 38.3%; 38.3%; 38.3%; 36.2%; 36.2%; 36.2%; 34%; 31.9%; 31.9%; 27.7%; 27.7%; 27.7%; 27.7%; 25.5%; 23.4%; 23.4%; 23.4%; 21.3%; 17%; 17%; 17%; 17%; 17%; 17%; 17%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; 14.9%; 17%; 19.2%; 21.3%; 19.2%; 17%; 14.9%; 12.8%; 32.8%; 31.2%; 31.2%; 29.5%; 29.5%; 26.2%; 24.6%; 24.6%; 24.6%; 23%; 23%; 23%; 23%; 19.7%; 14.8%; 13.1%; 11.5%; 14.8%; 13.1%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; 20.9%; 22.4%; 19.4%; 20.9%; 22.4%; 22.4%; 23.9%; 23.9%; 22.4%; 20.9%; 20.9%; 20.9%; 20.9%; 19.4%; 19.4%; 17.9%; 19.4%; 19.4%; 19.4%; 19.4%; 17.9%; 19.4%; 14.9%; 16.4%; 11.9%; 10.4%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; 10.4%; 9%; 9%; 7.5%; 10.4%; 9%; 7.5%; 9%; 7.5%; 7.5%; 6%; 7.5%; 7.5%; 7.5%; 7.5%; 7.5%; 9%; 10.4%; 13.4%; 14.9%; 14.9%; 19.4%; 19.4%; 19.4%; 20.9%; 20.9%; Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; 22.4%; 23.9%; 22.4%; 22.4%; 19.4%; 22.4%; 23.9%; 23.9%; 23.9%; 23.9%; 25.4%; 25.4%; 37.8%; 34.1%; 30.5%; 30.5%; 30.5%; 30.5%; 31.7%; 32.9%; 34.1%; 33%; 32.9%; 31.7%; 31.7%; 30.4%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; 30.5%; 30.5%; 31.7%; 30.5%; 30.5%; 25.6%; 25.6%; 25.6%; 23.2%; 22%; 22%; 20.7%; 23.2%; 18.3%; 18.3%; 14.6%; 12.2%; 12.2%; 11%; 13.4%. Allocation and on-board counts: Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 29. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 30. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 30. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 30. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 31. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 32. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 32. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 34. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 34. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 34. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 34. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 35. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 36. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 37. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007: SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 37. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC Allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 61; On-board counts by pay period: 53. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008: SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 59. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 60. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009: SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 62. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 60. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 58. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010: SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 53. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 67; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 51. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 54. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 55. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 56. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 201: SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 56. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 57. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 61. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 64. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 65. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 63. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 67. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 70. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 72. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 72. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 73. SEC Allocation: 82; On-board counts by pay period: 71. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] TSA: As figure 7 shows, from fiscal years 2006 through 2011, TSA's highest vacancy period was from January 2009 through April 2010, when it had a vacancy rate of 20 percent or more. In fiscal year 2008 TSA received an increased allocation of 14 positions, at which time its vacancy rate rose from 7.3 percent (11 vacant positions) to 15.9 percent (26 vacant positions); while, subsequent separations further raised the rate to a peak of 23.2 percent (38 vacant positions) in the first half of fiscal year 2010. For the remainder of fiscal year 2010 and in fiscal year 2011, TSA's vacancy rate was in the teens. TSA started fiscal year 2011 at 15.9 percent (21 vacant positions) and closed the year at 19.5 percent (32 vacant positions). According to TSA human capital officials, TSA's total allocation functions as a ceiling rather than a specific hiring target. Figure 7: TSA TSES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: 2 line graphs] Vacancy Rate: On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; 7.3%; 7.3%; 8%; 10%; 12%; 13.3%; 14%; 13.3%; 14%; 13.3%; 15.3%; 16%; 15.3%; 15.3%; 16.7%; 16.7%; 16.7%; 18.7%; 16.7%; 14.7%; 14%; 14%; 14%; 13.3%; 12.7%; 13.3%%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; 11.3%; 10.7%; 12%; 13.3%; 13.3%; 10.7%; 10.7%; 10%; 10.7%; 10.7%; 12.7%; 12.7%; 13.3%; 13.3%; 10.7%; 10.7%; 8%; 6.7%; 6.7%; 6.7%; 7.3%; 8%; 7.3%; 7.3%; 6.7%; 8%; 7.3%%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; 7.3%; 6.7%; 7.3%; 15.9%; 15.2%; 16.5%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.7%; 18.3%; 18.3%; 17.7%; 16.5%; 16.5%; 15.2%; 16.5%; 16.5%; 15.9%; 15.9%; 12.8%; 14%; 15.2%; 15.2%; 16.5%; 17.1%; 18.3%%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; 19.5%; 21.3%; 20.1%; 20.1%; 20.1%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 19.5%; 20.7%; 21.3%; 20.7%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 22.6%; 23.2%; 22%; 21.3%; 20.1%; 20.1%; 20.1%; 21.3%; 22%; 22.6%; 23.2%; 22.6%%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; 22.6%; 21.3%; 21.3%; 22%; 22%; 22%; 20.1%; 20.1%; 18.9%; 17.7%; 17.1%; 16.5%; 15.2%; 15.9%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 19.7%; 15.9%; 17.7%; 17.7%; 18.9%; 18.3%; 18.3%; 18.3%%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; 19.5%; 18.3%; 18.3%; 17.7%; 18.3%; 18.3%; 17.7%; 17.1%; 16.5%; 16.5%; 15.2%; 15.9%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 17.1%; 18.3%; 19.5%. Allocation and on-board counts: Fiscal year: 2006; TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 132. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 127. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 126. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 127. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 127. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 125. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 125. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 125. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 122. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 125. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 128. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. Fiscal year: 2007; TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 133. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 132. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 140. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 140. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 140. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 140. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. Fiscal year: 2008; TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 140. TSEC Allocation: 150; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 143. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 143. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. Fiscal year: 2009; TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 132. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 132. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 130. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 127. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 126. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 128. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 128. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 127. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 126. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 127. Fiscal year: 2010; TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 127. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 129. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 128. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 128. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 128. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 131. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 133. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 133. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. Fiscal year: 2011; TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 132. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 137. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 139. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 138. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 136. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 135. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 134. TSEC Allocation: 164; On-board counts by pay period: 132. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] USSS: Throughout the entire period, the USSS SES vacancy rates tended to be in the single digits. The highest vacancy rates occurred from May through July 2010, when the rate increased from 10.4 percent to 19.6 percent with the addition of three allocations and separations of two on-board staff. USSS started fiscal 2011 at 2.0 percent (1 vacancy) and ended the year at 0 percent (0 vacancies). Figure 8: USSS SES Vacancy Rates, Fiscal Years 2006 through 2011: [Refer to PDF for image: 2 line graphs] Vacancy Rate: On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2006; 0%; 2.3%; 4.7%; 4.7%; 4.7%; 4.7%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 4.7%; 2.3%; 9.3%; 9.3%; 11.6%; 11.6%; 7%; 2.3%; 0%; 0%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2007; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 2.3%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 6.4%; 8.5%; 8.5%; 0%; 2.1%; 0%; 0%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 4.3%; 4.3%; 8.5%; 8.5%; 8.5%; 8.5%; 2.1%; 0%; 0%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2008; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 0%; 0%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 6.3%; 4.2%; 4.2%; 6.3%; 10.4%; 8.3%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 4.2%; 2.1%; 4.2%; 4.2%; 4.2%; 2.1%; 0%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2009; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 2.1%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2010; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 2.1%; 4.2%; 6.3%; 8.3%; 10.4%; 14.6%; 14.6%; 19.6%; 5.9%; 2%; 2%; 3.9%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 3.9%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 2%; 3.9%. Fiscal year (bi-weekly pay periods): 2011; 3.9%; 2%; 5.9%; 5.9%; 3.9%; 3.9%; 3.9%; 3.9%; 2%; 2%; 3.9%; 3.9%; 3.9%; 3.9%; 2%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%; 0%. Allocation and on-board counts: Fiscal year: 2006; SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 39. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 38. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 40. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. Fiscal year: 2007; SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 42. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 43; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 47; On-board counts by pay period: 47. Fiscal year: 2008; SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. Fiscal year: 2009; SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. Fiscal year: 2010; SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 47. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 46. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 45. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 44. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 43. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 41. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 48; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. Fiscal year: 2011; SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 48. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 49. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 50. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 52. SEC allocation: 51; On-board counts by pay period: 51. Source: GAO analysis of NFC and OPM data. [End of figure] [End of section] Appendix II: Department of Homeland Security's Components Senior Leadership Attrition from 2006 to 2010: Tables 6-10 show the number and types of attrition for senior leadership positions in DHS components for each of the fiscal years from 2006 through 2010--the most recent year for which CPDF data were available--separated by career and noncareer positions.[Footnote 28] Table 6 shows the average number of on-board senior leadership positions and attrition rates in DHS components for each of the fiscal years from 2006-2010. Table 6: Fiscal Year 2006 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Agency: CBP; Career; Retired: 7; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 8. Agency: CBP; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 2. Agency: FEMA; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 8. Agency: FEMA; Noncareer; Retired: 1[B]; Resigned: 4; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 5. Agency: ICE; Career; Retired: 2; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 4. Agency: ICE; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: TSA; Career; Retired: 4; Resigned: 18; Transferred: 3; Terminated: 2; Other[A]: 0; Total: 27. Agency: TSA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCIS; Career; Retired: 3; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 3. Agency: USCIS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCG; Career; Retired: 1; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: USCG; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USSS; Career; Retired: 7; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 7. Agency: USSS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: DHS headquarters; Career; Retired: 10; Resigned: 5; Transferred: 5; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 20. Agency: DHS headquarters; Noncareer; Retired: 2; Resigned: 12; Transferred: 7; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 21. Agency: Total; Retired: 42 (39.6%); Resigned: 45 (42.5%); Transferred: 17 (16.0%); Terminated: 2; (1.9%); Other[A]: 0; (0.0%); Total: 106. Source: Data: GAO analysis of CPDF Data: [A] Other includes expiration of a limited term appointment and infrequent types of attrition, such as the death of an employee. A limited term appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment for a term of 3 years or less to an SES position the duties of which will expire at the end of such term. 5 U.S.C. § 3132(a)(5). A limited emergency appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment, not to exceed 18 months, to an SES position established to meet a bona fide, unanticipated, urgent need. § 3132(a)(6). [B] Career federal employees can be assigned to noncareer SES positions but retain their retirement eligibility. [End of table] Table 7: Fiscal Year 2007 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Agency: CBP; Career; Retired: 14; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 14. Agency: CBP; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: FEMA; Career; Retired: 1; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 2. Agency: FEMA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 4. Agency: ICE; Career; Retired: 8; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 9. Agency: ICE; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: TSA; Career; Retired: 6; Resigned: 6; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 3; Other[A]: 1; Total: 18. Agency: TSA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCIS; Career; Retired: 2; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 2. Agency: USCIS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: USCG; Career; Retired: 0; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 2. Agency: USCG; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USSS; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 5. Agency: USSS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: DHS headquarters; Career; Retired: 6; Resigned: 7; Transferred: 3; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 16. Agency: DHS headquarters; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 4; Transferred: 5; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 9. Agency: Total; Retired: 42 (50.0%); Resigned: 23 (27.4%); Transferred: 15 (17.9%); Terminated: 3 (3.6%); Other[A]: 1 (1.2%); Total: 84. Source: GAO analysis of CPDF Data. [A] Other includes expiration of a limited term appointment and infrequent types of attrition, such as the death of an employee. A limited appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment for a term of three years or less to an SES position the duties of which will expire at the end of such term. 5 U.S.C. § 3132(a)(5). A limited emergency appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment, not to exceed 18 months, to an SES position established to meet a bona fide, unanticipated, urgent need. § 3132(a)(6). [End of table] Table 8: Fiscal Year 2008 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Agency: CBP; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 7. Agency: CBP; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: FEMA; Career; Retired: 3; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 6. Agency: FEMA; Noncareer; Retired: 1; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 3. Agency: ICE; Career; Retired: 6; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 8. Agency: ICE; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: TSA; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 4; Transferred: 6; Terminated: 1; Other[A]: 0; Total: 16. Agency: TSA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCIS; Career; Retired: 1; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: USCIS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCG; Career; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCG; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USSS; Career; Retired: 11; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 11. Agency: USSS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: DHS headquarters; Career; Retired: 4; Resigned: 7; Transferred: 4; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 15. Agency: DHS headquarters; Noncareer; Retired: 1; Resigned: 9; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 11. Agency: Total; Retired: 37 (46.3%); Resigned: 28 (35.0%); Transferred: 14 (17.5%); Terminated: 1 (1.3%); Other[A]: 0 (0.0%); Total: 79. Source: GAO analysis of CPDF Data. [A] Other includes expiration of a limited term appointment and infrequent types of attrition, such as the death of an employee. A limited term appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment for a term of three years or less to an SES position the duties of which will expire at the end of such term. 5 U.S.C. § 3132(a)(5). A limited emergency appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment, not to exceed 18 months, to an SES position established to meet a bona fide, unanticipated, urgent need. § 3132(a)(6). [End of table] Table 9: Fiscal Year 2009 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Agency: CBP; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 7. Agency: CBP; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 4; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 4. Agency: FEMA; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 1; Total: 9. Agency: FEMA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 15; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 1; Other[A]: 0; Total: 16. Agency: ICE; Career; Retired: 4; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 1; Total: 9. Agency: ICE; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 3; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 3. Agency: TSA; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 12; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 3; Other[A]: 1; Total: 23. Agency: TSA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCIS; Career; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 1; Total: 1. Agency: USCIS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 5; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 5. Agency: USCG; Career; Retired: 1; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: USCG; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USSS; Career; Retired: 3; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 3. Agency: USSS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: DHS headquarters; Career; Retired: 4; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 3; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 1; Total: 10. Agency: DHS headquarters; Noncareer; Retired: 3; Resigned: 31; Transferred: 3; Terminated: 2; Other[A]: 0; Total: 39. Agency: Total; Retired: 30 (23.1%); Resigned: 77 (59.2%); Transferred: 12 (9.2%); Terminated: 6 (4.6%); Other[A]: 5 (3.8%); Total: 130. Source: GAO analysis of CPDF Data. [A] Other includes expiration of a limited term appointment and infrequent types of attrition, such as the death of an employee. A limited term appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment for a term of three years or less to an SES position the duties of which will expire at the end of such term. 5 U.S.C. § 3132(a)(5). A limited emergency appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment, not to exceed 18 months, to an SES position established to meet a bona fide, unanticipated, urgent need. § 3132(a)(6). [End of table] Table 10: Fiscal Year 2010 DHS-Component Senior-Leadership Separations: Agency: CBP; Career; Retired: 9; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 3; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 1; Total: 14. Agency: CBP; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: FEMA; Career; Retired: 1; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 3; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 5. Agency: FEMA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: ICE; Career; Retired: 5; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 2; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 1; Total: 9. Agency: ICE; Noncareer; Retired: 1[B]; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 1. Agency: TSA; Career; Retired: 3; Resigned: 2; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 2; Other[A]: 1; Total: 9. Agency: TSA; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCIS; Career; Retired: 4; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 1; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 5. Agency: USCIS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCG; Career; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USCG; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: USSS; Career; Retired: 9; Resigned: 1; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 10. Agency: USSS; Noncareer; Retired: 0; Resigned: 0; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 0; Other[A]: 0; Total: 0. Agency: DHS headquarters; Career; Retired: 4; Resigned: 8; Transferred: 6; Terminated: 1; Other[A]: 0; Total: 19. Agency: DHS headquarters; Noncareer; Retired: 2; Resigned: 3; Transferred: 0; Terminated: 1; Other[A]: 0; Total: 6. Agency: Total; Retired: 38 (48.1%); Resigned: 18 (22.8%); Transferred: 16 (20.3%); Terminated: 4 (5.1%); Other[A]: 3 (3.8%); Total: 79. Source: GAO Analysis of CPDF Data. [A] Other includes expiration of a limited term appointment and infrequent types of attrition, such as the death of an employee. A limited term appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment for a term of three years or less to an SES position the duties of which will expire at the end of such term. 5 U.S.C. § 3132(a)(5). A limited emergency appointee is an individual appointed under a nonrenewable appointment, not to exceed 18 months, to an SES position established to meet a bona fide, unanticipated, urgent need. § 3132(a)(6). [B] Career federal employees can be assigned to noncareer SES positions but retain their retirement eligibility. [End of table] Table 11 shows the component vacancy rates by fiscal year from 2006- 2010. Table 11: DHS Components' Attrition Rates by Fiscal Year: Component: USCIS; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 16.0; Rate: 18.8%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 24.0; Rate: 12.5%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 40.5; Rate: 2.5;% Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 48.0; Rate: 12.5%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 45.5; Rate: 11.0%. Component: CBP; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 66.5; Rate: 15.0%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 74.0; Rate: 20.3%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 89.0; Rate: 9.0%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 103.0; Rate: 10.7%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 101.0; Rate: 13.9%. Component: FEMA; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 35.0; Rate: 34.3%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 43.0; Rate: 14.0%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 55.0; Rate: 18.2%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 58.0; Rate: 37.9%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 60.0; Rate: 10.0%. Component: ICE; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 33.0; Rate: 12.1%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 42.0; Rate: 23.8%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 51.0; Rate: 15.7%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 56.5; Rate: 21.2%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 57.0; Rate: 17.5%. Component: TSA; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 144.0; Rate: 18.8%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 139.0; Rate: 12.9%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 144.0; Rate: 11.1%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 137.5; Rate: 16.7%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 136.0; Rate: 6.6%. Component: USCG; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 7.5; Rate: 13.3%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 9.0; Rate: 22.2%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 11.5; Rate: 0.0%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 13.0; Rate: 7.7%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 14.5; Rate: 0.0%. Component: USSS; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 40.5; Rate: 17.3%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 44.5; Rate: 11.2%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 47.5; Rate: 23.2%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 49.5; Rate: 6.1%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 51.0; Rate: 19.6%. Component: DHS average; Fiscal Year: 2006: Average on board: 474.5; Rate: 22.1%; Fiscal Year: 2007: Average on board: 533; Rate: 15.8%; Fiscal Year: 2008: Average: on board: 629; Rate: 12.7%; Fiscal Year: 2009: Average on board: 680.5; Rate: 18.7%; Fiscal Year: 2010: Average on board[A]: 690.5; Rate: 11.4%. Source: GAO analysis of CPDF Data. [A] We calculated average on-board figures by averaging (1) the number of senior executive staff in the CPDF as of the last pay period of the fiscal year prior to the fiscal year for which the attrition rate was calculated and (2) the number of senior executive staff in CPDF as of the last pay period of the fiscal year in which the attrition occurred. [End of table] [End of section] Appendix III: Comments from the Department of Homeland Security: U.S. Department of Homeland Security: Washington, DC 20528: February 2, 2012: David C. Maurer: Director, Homeland Security and Justice Issues: U.S. Government Accountability Office: 441 G Street, NW: Washington, DC 20548: Re: Draft Report GAO-12-264, "DHS Human Capital: Senior Leadership Vacancy Rates Have Generally Declined, but Components' Rates Have Varied" Dear Mr. Maurer, Thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on the subject draft report. The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) appreciates the U.S. Government Accountability Office's (GAO's) work in planning and conducting its review and issuing this report. The Department is strongly committed to filling senior leadership vacancies in an expeditious and responsible manner. DHS is pleased to note GAO's positive recognition of actions its taken to implement programs addressing senior leadership hiring and recruitment. These include the Department's use of the Office of Personnel Management's (OPM's) resume-only recruitment and hiring process, which helped reduce DHS vacancy rates by significantly improving DHS's ability to (1) attract highly qualified senior executives, and (2) fill 90 newly allocated SES positions from OPM's biennial review. The lessons learned from using this process have been invaluable and DHS human capital personnel are sharing them across the Federal Government with others, including counterparts at the Departments of Veterans Affairs, Labor, Energy, Agriculture, State, and Housing and Urban Development. More specifically, our personnel are serving as mentors and coaches helping others determine how best to implement the resume-only recruitment and hiring process at their Departments. We note the report does not contain any recommendations for DHS. Technical comments were previously submitted under separate cover. Again, thank you for the opportunity to review and comment on this draft report. We look forward to working with you on future Homeland Security issues. Sincerely, Signed by: Jim H. Crumpacker: Director: Departmental GAO-OIG Liaison Office: [End of section] Appendix IV: GAO Contact and Staff Acknowledgments: GAO Contact: David C. Maurer, (202) 512-9627 or maurerd@gao.gov: Staff Acknowledgments: In addition to the contact named above, Sandra Burrell, Assistant Director; Rebecca Gambler, Assistant Director; George Erhart; Kathryn Godfrey; Jared Hermalin; and Celia Mendive made significant contributions to the work. Ben Atwater, Justin Dunleavy, and Jean Orland also contributed. Muriel Brown and Robert Robinson assisted with graphic design. Steven Putansu and Greg Wilmoth assisted with design, methodology, and analysis. Thomas Lombardi provided legal support. Lara Miklozek and Linda Miller provided communications expertise. [End of section] Footnotes: [1] Committee on Homeland Security (Majority Staff) Report: Critical Leadership Vacancies Impede United States Department of Homeland Security (Washington, D.C.: July 2007) and National Association of Public Administration: Addressing the 2009 Presidential Transition at the Department of Homeland Security (Washington, D.C.: June 2008) [2] GAO, Human Capital: Bonuses to Senior Executives at the Department of Veterans Affairs, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-07-985T] (Washington, D.C.: June 12, 2007). [3] GAO, Older Workers: Federal Agencies Face Challenges but Have Opportunities to Hire and Retain Experienced Employees, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-08-630T] (Washington, D.C.: Apr. 30, 2008). [4] GAO, High-Risk Series: An Update, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-03-119] (Washington, D.C.: January 2003). [5] GAO, High-Risk Series: An Update, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-11-278] (Washington, D.C.: February 2011). [6] Discussions of SES in this report include the Transportation Security Administration's SES equivalent, the Transportation Security Executive Service. [7] For the purposes of this report, senior leadership vacancies include any unfilled senior leadership positions at DHS established pursuant to allocations by (or in the case of the Transportation Security Administration, pursuant to an agreement with OPM. See, e.g., 5 C.F.R. § 330.101(b). [8] Most DHS components were not allocated SL or ST positions during the 2006 through 2011 review period. Specifically, only CBP received ST allocations during this time frame. Less than half the components received SL allocations--never exceeding a total of three positions. As of the end of fiscal year 2011, DHS had a total of 65 SL and ST allocations, 60 of which were spread among DHS headquarters offices. The Office of the Undersecretary for Science and Technology is the only office to have received more than eight SL and ST allocations. [9] DHS-provided data on OPM allocations were not computer processed. OPM informs federal departments of their allocations via written letter. DHS provided us with copies of the OPM letters it received during the time frame of our review. [10] On-board data for October through December 2005 were not available because recoding and reorganization that took place in 2005 may have led to data reliability concerns. Our fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January through September 2006. [11] See 31 U.S.C. § 901 (identifying 24 agencies subject to requirements of the CFO Act). As of 2009, CFO Act agencies employed 98 percent of all federal employees. OPM's Central Personnel Data File is a repository of selected human capital data for most executive branch employees, including separation data. OPM's Executive Schedule C System is a database that tracks OPM allocations of SES positions to federal agencies. Schedule C positions are excepted from the competitive service because of the confidential or policy-determining nature of the position duties. [12] See [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-10-139] and GAO, OPM's Central Personnel Data File: Data Appear Sufficiently Reliable to Meet Most Customer Needs, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO/GGD-98-199] (Washington, D.C.: September 1998). [13] Agencies may use up to 3 percent of their SES allocations for limited term appointments. See 5 C.F.R. §317.601(c). A limited term appointee may not serve in that capacity in excess of 36 months. See 5 C.F.R. §§ 317.602(c), 604(b)(2). [14] For the purposes of this report, when we use the term allocation in connection with OPM, we are referring to an authorization by OPM for an agency to fill an established number of SES, SL, or ST positions. See 5 U.S.C. §§ 3104, 3133, and 5108. Senior leadership positions for TSA are not directly allocated by OPM, but are arranged under agreement between DHS and OPM. See, e.g., 49 U.S.C. §§ 114(n) (applying, in general, the personnel management system established by the Federal Aviation Administration--a system that, with certain exceptions, falls outside the authority of OPM and is to provide for greater flexibility in hiring, training, compensation, and location of personnel--to TSA). [15] Because of the low number of SL and ST positions allocated among the components, our vacancy rate calculations are for SES positions only. [16] See GAO, Transportation Security Administration: TSA Executive Attrition Has Declined, but Better Information Is Needed on Reasons for Leaving and Executive Hiring Process, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-10-139] (Washington, D.C.: Oct. 2009). [17] Data for fiscal year 2011 were not yet available in OPM's CPDF at the time of this review. [18] GAO, Homeland Security: DHS's Actions to Recruit and Retain Staff and Comply with the Vacancies Reform Act, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-07-758] (Washington, D.C., Jul. 16, 2007). [19] GAO, Standards for Internal Control in the Federal Government, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO/AIMD-00-21.3.1] (Washington, D.C., November 1999). [20] GAO, Human Capital: Key Principles for Effective Strategic Workforce Planning, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-04-39] (Washington, D.C., Dec. 11, 2003). [21] GAO, Federal Aviation Administration: Human Capital System Incorporates Many Leading Practices, but Improving Employees' Satisfaction with Their Workplace Remains a Challenge, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-10-89] (Washington, D.C., Oct. 28, 2009). [22] The ECQs were developed in 1997 after extensive research on the attributes of successful executives in both the private and public sectors. They were revalidated and reissued with a few modifications in 2006. In their current form, they represent the best thinking of organizational psychologists, human resources professionals both at OPM and other agencies, and Senior Executives themselves. The ECQs are: (1) leading change, (2) leading people, (3) results driven, (4) business acumen, and (5) building coalitions. [23] GAO, Human Capital: Transforming Federal Recruiting and Hiring Efforts, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-08-762T] (Washington, D.C., May 8, 2008). [24] According to DHS OCHCO, of the 6 remaining positions, 2 are in the recruitment phase and 4 are on hold pending decisions about organizational placement. [25] [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-07-758]. [26] All senior executives must have their executive qualifications certified by an OPM Qualifications Review Board before being appointed as career members of the SES. See 5 C.F.R. § 317.502(a). The Qualifications Review Board review and certification is the last critical step in the SES selection process. Among other things, Qualification Review Boards will determine whether a candidate has demonstrated executive qualifications sufficient for entry into the SES. [27] On-board data for October-December 2005 were not available. Our fiscal year 2006 vacancy calculation is for January-September 2006. [28] According to OPM, a career appointee is an SES whose appointment to the position was based on a competitive SES merit staffing process and whose executive qualifications for the SES were certified by a Qualifications Review Board or an individual who converted to the SES with a career appointment. A non-career appointee was appointed noncompetitively to an SES position, and non-career SES positions are limited or emergency term appointments. [End of section] GAO’s Mission: The Government Accountability Office, the audit, evaluation, and investigative arm of Congress, exists to support Congress in meeting its constitutional responsibilities and to help improve the performance and accountability of the federal government for the American people. GAO examines the use of public funds; evaluates federal programs and policies; and provides analyses, recommendations, and other assistance to help Congress make informed oversight, policy, and funding decisions. GAO’s commitment to good government is reflected in its core values of accountability, integrity, and reliability. Obtaining Copies of GAO Reports and Testimony: The fastest and easiest way to obtain copies of GAO documents at no cost is through GAO’s website [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov]. Each weekday afternoon, GAO posts on its website newly released reports, testimony, and correspondence. To have GAO e-mail you a list of newly posted products, go to [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov] and select “E- mail Updates.” Order by Phone: The price of each GAO publication reflects GAO’s actual cost of production and distribution and depends on the number of pages in the publication and whether the publication is printed in color or black and white. Pricing and ordering information is posted on GAO’s website, [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/ordering.htm]. Place orders by calling (202) 512-6000, toll free (866) 801-7077, or TDD (202) 512-2537. Orders may be paid for using American Express, Discover Card, MasterCard, Visa, check, or money order. Call for additional information. Connect with GAO: Connect with GAO on facebook, flickr, twitter, and YouTube. Subscribe to our RSS Feeds or E mail Updates. Listen to our Podcasts. Visit GAO on the web at [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov]. To Report Fraud, Waste, and Abuse in Federal Programs: Contact: Website: [hyperlink, http://www.gao.gov/fraudnet/fraudnet.htm]; E-mail: fraudnet@gao.gov; Automated answering system: (800) 424-5454 or (202) 512-7470. Congressional Relations: Katherine Siggerud, Managing Director, siggerudk@gao.gov, (202) 512-4400 U.S. Government Accountability Office, 441 G Street NW, Room 7125 Washington, DC 20548. Public Affairs: Chuck Young, Managing Director, youngc1@gao.gov, (202) 512-4800 U.S. Government Accountability Office, 441 G Street NW, Room 7149 Washington, DC 20548.